On Sat, 13 Nov 2004 13:48:04 +0000, Andy Green <fedora@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: Bah... I've seen several people list a minimal set of packages.. but i have yet to see a comps.xml file offered for community testing. This discussion has happened ever release cycle of fedora. The list archives have several packages lists that define a minimal installation. But I have not seen ONE comps.xml file offered that people in the community can test. A list of packages is as far as any discussion ever gets, but what is needed is a working comps.xml file that people can test and provide feedback on... if people in the community are truely interested in getting a better minimal install available for the next release. The long list of packages adds zero value to the discussion, the comps.xml this guy created is still not available. -jef