Ok, so after reading through the (rather long) threads on comps.xml, autogeneration, etc, etc, two things stuck in my head from it. 1) It's not always desirable for all packages to be in comps (perl-*, python-*, etc). 2) We need an automated way to tell if a package should be left out of comps, or if its omission was an oversight. So... while waiting for the package db, would it be possible to use a cvs "flag" file along the lines of what we do with needs.rebuild? e.g., a branch directory contains: * 'no.comps' as an empty (or containing reason why) file if it should not be listed in comps, or * 'comps' as a file with the groups (one per line) it should be listed under. This would give an easy, per branch way to determine if a package should be listed in comps, if so where, or if it's being intentionally left out by the maintainer. Automated scripts can look for these to add packages or rebuild comps*.in; branches missing the file can have "huh?" notes generated to owners or summary to extras list. It has the added advantage of allowing maintainers to keep this info directly with the package. Thoughts? Good / bad / crazy? -Chris -- Chris Weyl Ex astris, scientia -- fedora-extras-list mailing list fedora-extras-list@xxxxxxxxxx https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-extras-list