Peter Gordon wrote: > Rex Dieter wrote: >> Patrice Dumas wrote: > [...] >>> In the Guidelines, there is >>> The preferred value for the BuildRoot tag is >>> ..... >>> What [does it] means exactly? I was under the impression that this was >>> a MUST item. >> If the Guidelines don't *say* MUST, it isn't. So, no. > Well, alot of the Guidelines don't explicitly require a strict convention. > However, for the sake of clarity and because this is generally a blocker > on review requests, I believe it best for this guideline to be considered > a MUST. Some members of the packaging committee (me, at least) disagree making this a MUST. Of course, it's a reviewers' prerogative how seriously to treat non-MUST items. IMO, in this case, since it is not a MUST item, non-broken BuildRoots (that don't match the "preferred" value) shouldn't be blocker. -- Rex -- fedora-extras-list mailing list fedora-extras-list@xxxxxxxxxx https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-extras-list
