On Fri, 6 Sept 2024 at 09:49, Miroslav Suchý <msuchy@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > Bellow is list of packages that have licenses that are neither valid as Callaway nor as SPDX. I.e. the license cannot be validated neither using 'license-validate' nor using 'license-validate --old'. > > Some examples I checked (random selection): > > aldo.spec: > License: GPL-2.0-or-later AND GPL-3.0 > (typo in GPL-3.0) > > plasma-mobile.spec: > License: CC0 and GPLv2 and GPLv2+ and GPLv3 and GPLv3+ and LGPLv2+ and LGPLv2.1 and LGPLv2.1+ and LGPLv3 and LGPLv3 and MIT > ( we do not track LGPLv2.1 and LGPLv2.1+ in Callaway system) > > qcad.spec > License: GPL-3.0-only AND GPL-2.0-or-later AND MIT AND BSD AND Public Domain AND CC-BY-3.0 AND Hershey > (old form of BSD and PD, unknown license Heshey) > > zeromq.spec: > License: MPLv2.0 AND BSD-3-Clause AND MIT > (old form of MPL) > > I wonder how to approach this? > > Either: > > 1) Directly change it in dist-git to LicenseRef-Callaway-$OLD_ID with a comment that maintainer should revise it. Or What about a PR? I've not seen anything for my U-Boot package listed > 2) Open BZs for these packages. > > I will welcome your comments and opinions. > > There is 236 such cases in Fedora. > > Maintainers by package: > Coin3 corsepiu hobbes1069 jkastner > Mayavi chedi orion > OpenSceneGraph smani > ProDy sagitter > R-IRanges spot > R-lubridate qulogic > abi-dumper hobbes1069 orion > accel-config miaojun0823 yunyings > ags rathann > aldo hobbes1069 > alsa-sof-firmware perex > angelfish kkofler thunderbirdtr > api-sanity-checker hobbes1069 > aprsdigi hobbes1069 > aqbanking limb rdieter > audacious-plugins danfruehauf mschwendt robert > avogadro2-libs sagitter > bacula slaanesh > bijiben mcrha pwalter > bmake pemensik > bsh didiksupriadi41 mizdebsk > btop jonathanspw > build2 mkrupcale > c4core music > calf limb > ceph branto kkeithle ktdreyer > clamav gnat mstevens nb orion pwouters robert sergiomb steve > clementine eclipseo > cmake besser82 orion pwalter rdieter > collectl kzak sharkcz > cross-binutils dhowells lkundrak sharkcz > dcfldd rebus > dumpasn1 fkooman > fcitx5-mozc music yanqiyu > fedora-remix-logos spot > fedora-workstation-backgrounds duffy luya ryanlerch > filebench hushan > fldigi hobbes1069 > flmsg hobbes1069 > fltk aarem hobbes1069 jchaloup phracek rdieter > frescobaldi limb > gdb-exploitable sgrubb > generic-release bruno mohanboddu spot > ghc-control-monad-free mathstuf petersen > ghc-http-client qulogic > ghc-hxt-unicode petersen > ghc-monad-loops petersen > ghc-polyparse petersen > ghc-tf-random petersen > ghc-uglymemo mathstuf > ghostwriter marcdeop > gi-docgen music > gl-manpages ajax yaneti > gmsh hobbes1069 ignatenkobrain jkastner smani > gnote kalev > gnu-free-fonts limb > golang-gopkg-retry-1 eclipseo > golang-gopkg-yaml-1 mikelo2 > gstreamer1-doc wtaymans > guayadeque martinkg > hackrf cottsay jskarvad stevenfalco > hibernate-jpa-2.0-api jjelen > hydra rcallicotte rebus > icecat kengert sagitter > iprutils dwmw2 jcajka sinnykumari > iucode-tool duck puiterwijk > jam spot > jbosscache-support orphan > jsmath-fonts rdieter > julia nalimilan > julius spot > kcbench thl > kclock thunderbirdtr > kernel acaringi airlied ajax bskeggs jcline jforbes jwboyer jwrdegoede kernel-maint linville myoung patrickt quintela sandeen steved > kf5-bluez-qt jgrulich rdieter > kf5-kcalendarcore rdieter > kf5-kdeclarative jgrulich rdieter than > kf5-kholidays rdieter > kf5-kirigami2 rdieter > kf5-kirigami2-addons thunderbirdtr > kf5-krunner jgrulich rdieter than > kf5-libkleo jkucera rdieter > kf5-threadweaver jgrulich rdieter than > khealthcertificate ngompa thunderbirdtr > kpublictransport ngompa thunderbirdtr > kscreen rdieter > lazarus suve > libclc ignatenkobrain nikic sergesanspaille tstellar tuliom > libnumbertext limb > libpri music > libtimidity aekoroglu jwrdegoede sagitter > libva-intel-hybrid-driver kwizart > libwebp smani > lmms thm > lumina-desktop tieugene > luminance-hdr music > lyx jamatos rdieter > maatkit slankes > man-pages-ja tagoh > man-pages-l10n ljavorsk mfabian nforro > man2html orion patches sergiomb > mariadb10.11 fjanus hhorak ljavorsk mschorm zmiklank > mingw-binutils elmarco etrunko kalev rjones smani > mingw-libunistring etrunko > mingw-wxWidgets sailer > mingw-wxWidgets3 sailer > moby-engine buckaroogeek copperi gotmax23 sergiomb > mxml kevin > net-snmp jridky jsafrane zdohnal > newsx rathann > nikto huzaifas rebus > ocaml-camomile avsej rjones > ocaml-omake rjones > ogre dtimms ignatenkobrain sergiomb > open-vm-tools jwolfe ravindrakumar rjones slaanesh > opencascade hobbes1069 > opendkim mdomsch > opendmarc kevin > openexr hobbes1069 jridky > openjfx deamn > openjfx8 deamn > perl-Crypt-Blowfish ixs > perl-Data-Validate-IP swt2c > perl-Devel-Caller-IgnoreNamespaces eseyman > perl-HTML-TableExtract limb > perl-License-Syntax jplesnik ppisar > perl-Lingua-Preferred eseyman xavierb > perl-LockFile-Simple ixs > perl-Unicode-CheckUTF8 pghmcfc > perl-XML-Tiny cicku eseyman > perl-qooxdoo-compat terjeros > php-pear-PHP-CodeSniffer cdamian remi > phpMyAdmin remi robert > pinball limb sergiomb > pkcs11-helper dwmw2 kalev > plasma-mobile farchord > pokerth pwalter > proj devrim neteler smani > publican jfearn rlandmann > pypy churchyard thrnciar > pypy3.10 churchyard > pypy3.9 churchyard thrnciar > python-basemap limb > python-cclib sagitter > python-graph-tool ankursinha > python-llvmlite ankursinha > python-pdfminer music > python-pyface chedi ignatenkobrain orion > python-stone limb > python-traitsui chedi ignatenkobrain orion > python-utmp jpopelka tuju > python3.13 churchyard ksurma > qcad sagitter > qmmp kvolny > qownnotes atim > qt5-qtfeedback jgrulich rdieter > rgbds blowry > rpminspect dcantrell > ruby mtasaka vondruch > rubygem-rdoc vondruch > rubygem-xmlparser schwicke > rust-askalono-cli decathorpe > rust-dutree kalev > rust-gmp-mpfr-sys dcavalca > rust-just alebastr > rust-nettle decathorpe > rust-nettle-sys decathorpe > rust-rav1e decathorpe > rust-rpick bowlofeggs > rust-ybaas decathorpe > rust-yubibomb decathorpe > rust-zbase32 decathorpe > scalasca loveshack > scantailor xhorak > scummvm chkr lucilanga > sequeler music > simple-scan amigadave dodji ignatenkobrain slaanesh > sipp peter > skf mtasaka > strace esyr ldv vda > stun huzaifas > subscription-manager csnyder jhnidek ptoscano > subscription-manager-rhsm-certificates csnyder jhnidek ptoscano > supertuxkart ignatenkobrain limb pwalter rmattes > sympa xavierb > tcmu-runner mlombard > teeworlds ignatenkobrain limb lkundrak > texlive jnovy spot than > thc-ipv6 neil robert > tkimg spot > tlog jstephen nkondras > torque hguemar spot > tuxpaint-stamps cbm limb steve > uboot-tools ausil pbrobinson sharkcz > upx limb > usd aekoroglu luya music slaanesh > vakzination farchord thunderbirdtr > virtualbox-guest-additions jwrdegoede sergiomb > w3m robert > webkitgtk catanzaro > wsdlpull denisarnaud > wwl jskarvad > wxsqlite3 martinkg > xmedcon ankursinha > yakuake rdieter > yascreen bbonev1 > zeromq denisarnaud stevetraylen tomspur > > Packages by maintainer: > aarem fltk > acaringi kernel > aekoroglu libtimidity usd > airlied kernel > ajax gl-manpages kernel > alebastr rust-just > amigadave simple-scan > ankursinha python-graph-tool python-llvmlite xmedcon > atim qownnotes > ausil uboot-tools > avsej ocaml-camomile > bbonev1 yascreen > besser82 cmake > blowry rgbds > bowlofeggs rust-rpick > branto ceph > bruno generic-release > bskeggs kernel > buckaroogeek moby-engine > catanzaro webkitgtk > cbm tuxpaint-stamps > cdamian php-pear-PHP-CodeSniffer > chedi Mayavi python-pyface python-traitsui > chkr scummvm > churchyard pypy pypy3.10 pypy3.9 python3.13 > cicku perl-XML-Tiny > copperi moby-engine > corsepiu Coin3 > cottsay hackrf > csnyder subscription-manager subscription-manager-rhsm-certificates > danfruehauf audacious-plugins > dcantrell rpminspect > dcavalca rust-gmp-mpfr-sys > deamn openjfx openjfx8 > decathorpe rust-askalono-cli rust-nettle rust-nettle-sys rust-rav1e rust-ybaas rust-yubibomb rust-zbase32 > denisarnaud wsdlpull zeromq > devrim proj > dhowells cross-binutils > didiksupriadi41 bsh > dodji simple-scan > dtimms ogre > duck iucode-tool > duffy fedora-workstation-backgrounds > dwmw2 iprutils pkcs11-helper > eclipseo clementine golang-gopkg-retry-1 > elmarco mingw-binutils > eseyman perl-Devel-Caller-IgnoreNamespaces perl-Lingua-Preferred perl-XML-Tiny > esyr strace > etrunko mingw-binutils mingw-libunistring > farchord plasma-mobile vakzination > fjanus mariadb10.11 > fkooman dumpasn1 > gnat clamav > gotmax23 moby-engine > hguemar torque > hhorak mariadb10.11 > hobbes1069 Coin3 abi-dumper aldo api-sanity-checker aprsdigi fldigi flmsg fltk gmsh opencascade openexr > hushan filebench > huzaifas nikto stun > ignatenkobrain gmsh libclc ogre python-pyface python-traitsui simple-scan supertuxkart teeworlds > ixs perl-Crypt-Blowfish perl-LockFile-Simple > jamatos lyx > jcajka iprutils > jchaloup fltk > jcline kernel > jfearn publican > jforbes kernel > jgrulich kf5-bluez-qt kf5-kdeclarative kf5-krunner kf5-threadweaver qt5-qtfeedback > jhnidek subscription-manager subscription-manager-rhsm-certificates > jjelen hibernate-jpa-2.0-api > jkastner Coin3 gmsh > jkucera kf5-libkleo > jnovy texlive > jonathanspw btop > jplesnik perl-License-Syntax > jpopelka python-utmp > jridky net-snmp openexr > jsafrane net-snmp > jskarvad hackrf wwl > jstephen tlog > jwboyer kernel > jwolfe open-vm-tools > jwrdegoede kernel libtimidity virtualbox-guest-additions > kalev gnote mingw-binutils pkcs11-helper rust-dutree > kengert icecat > kernel-maint kernel > kevin mxml opendmarc > kkeithle ceph > kkofler angelfish > ksurma python3.13 > ktdreyer ceph > kvolny qmmp > kwizart libva-intel-hybrid-driver > kzak collectl > ldv strace > limb aqbanking calf frescobaldi gnu-free-fonts libnumbertext perl-HTML-TableExtract pinball python-basemap python-stone supertuxkart teeworlds tuxpaint-stamps upx > linville kernel > ljavorsk man-pages-l10n mariadb10.11 > lkundrak cross-binutils teeworlds > loveshack scalasca > lucilanga scummvm > luya fedora-workstation-backgrounds usd > marcdeop ghostwriter > martinkg guayadeque wxsqlite3 > mathstuf ghc-control-monad-free ghc-uglymemo > mcrha bijiben > mdomsch opendkim > mfabian man-pages-l10n > miaojun0823 accel-config > mikelo2 golang-gopkg-yaml-1 > mizdebsk bsh > mkrupcale build2 > mlombard tcmu-runner > mohanboddu generic-release > mschorm mariadb10.11 > mschwendt audacious-plugins > mstevens clamav > mtasaka ruby skf > music c4core fcitx5-mozc gi-docgen libpri luminance-hdr python-pdfminer sequeler usd > myoung kernel > nalimilan julia > nb clamav > neil thc-ipv6 > neteler proj > nforro man-pages-l10n > ngompa khealthcertificate kpublictransport > nikic libclc > nkondras tlog > orion Mayavi abi-dumper clamav cmake man2html python-pyface python-traitsui > orphan jbosscache-support > patches man2html > patrickt kernel > pbrobinson uboot-tools > pemensik bmake > perex alsa-sof-firmware > peter sipp > petersen ghc-control-monad-free ghc-hxt-unicode ghc-monad-loops ghc-polyparse ghc-tf-random > pghmcfc perl-Unicode-CheckUTF8 > phracek fltk > ppisar perl-License-Syntax > ptoscano subscription-manager subscription-manager-rhsm-certificates > puiterwijk iucode-tool > pwalter bijiben cmake pokerth supertuxkart > pwouters clamav > quintela kernel > qulogic R-lubridate ghc-http-client > rathann ags newsx > ravindrakumar open-vm-tools > rcallicotte hydra > rdieter aqbanking cmake fltk jsmath-fonts kf5-bluez-qt kf5-kcalendarcore kf5-kdeclarative kf5-kholidays kf5-kirigami2 kf5-krunner kf5-libkleo kf5-threadweaver kscreen lyx qt5-qtfeedback yakuake > rebus dcfldd hydra nikto > remi php-pear-PHP-CodeSniffer phpMyAdmin > rjones mingw-binutils ocaml-camomile ocaml-omake open-vm-tools > rlandmann publican > rmattes supertuxkart > robert audacious-plugins clamav phpMyAdmin thc-ipv6 w3m > ryanlerch fedora-workstation-backgrounds > sagitter ProDy avogadro2-libs icecat libtimidity python-cclib qcad > sailer mingw-wxWidgets mingw-wxWidgets3 > sandeen kernel > schwicke rubygem-xmlparser > sergesanspaille libclc > sergiomb clamav man2html moby-engine ogre pinball virtualbox-guest-additions > sgrubb gdb-exploitable > sharkcz collectl cross-binutils uboot-tools > sinnykumari iprutils > slaanesh bacula open-vm-tools simple-scan usd > slankes maatkit > smani OpenSceneGraph gmsh libwebp mingw-binutils proj > spot R-IRanges fedora-remix-logos generic-release jam julius texlive tkimg torque > steve clamav tuxpaint-stamps > steved kernel > stevenfalco hackrf > stevetraylen zeromq > suve lazarus > swt2c perl-Data-Validate-IP > tagoh man-pages-ja > terjeros perl-qooxdoo-compat > than kf5-kdeclarative kf5-krunner kf5-threadweaver texlive > thl kcbench > thm lmms > thrnciar pypy pypy3.9 > thunderbirdtr angelfish kclock kf5-kirigami2-addons khealthcertificate kpublictransport vakzination > tieugene lumina-desktop > tomspur zeromq > tstellar libclc > tuju python-utmp > tuliom libclc > vda strace > vondruch ruby rubygem-rdoc > wtaymans gstreamer1-doc > xavierb perl-Lingua-Preferred sympa > xhorak scantailor > yaneti gl-manpages > yanqiyu fcitx5-mozc > yunyings accel-config > zdohnal net-snmp > zmiklank mariadb10.11 > > -- > Miroslav Suchy, RHCA > Red Hat, Manager, Packit and CPT, #brno, #fedora-buildsys > > -- > _______________________________________________ > devel mailing list -- devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx > To unsubscribe send an email to devel-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx > Fedora Code of Conduct: https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/project/code-of-conduct/ > List Guidelines: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines > List Archives: https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx > Do not reply to spam, report it: https://pagure.io/fedora-infrastructure/new_issue -- _______________________________________________ devel mailing list -- devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx To unsubscribe send an email to devel-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Fedora Code of Conduct: https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/project/code-of-conduct/ List Guidelines: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines List Archives: https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Do not reply to spam, report it: https://pagure.io/fedora-infrastructure/new_issue
