Proposal to fail builds if RPATH is found in Fedora 35

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



Hi all.

Some time ago there was a discussion from the Fedora Packaging Committee [0] about automatically disallowing the usage of RPATH in Fedora to bring it in-line with the packaging guidelines[1]. Essentially a package MUST remove the RPATH entry from its binaries and/or .so files if it is detected by the check-rpaths script [2] coming from the rpm-build package.

However, the script was never run during rpmbuild so it was on the discretion of the packager if they'd check for it or not. The intention is to enable the check through redhat-rpm-config during the the invocation of  %__os_install_post. An opt-out mechanism will be provided for cases where it's absolutely necessary.

After an analysis of all the x86_64 packages, 92 fail to build due to an RPATH issue detected by the check-rpaths script [3]. Full list is provided bellow.

Everything will be implemented through a Fedora change and all the packagers that their package has been affected by the preliminary analysis will be contacted first.

Thoughts and feedback are welcome.

[0] https://pagure.io/packaging-committee/issue/886
[1] https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/packaging-guidelines/#_beware_of_rpath
[2] https://github.com/rpm-software-management/rpm/blob/6b21e736a3e47071b33ff7c34e5cfb5447997e18/scripts/check-rpaths-worker
[3] https://copr.fedorainfracloud.org/coprs/cstratak/rpath/builds/

List of packages affected so far:

Maintainers by package: 
Io-language          limb 
NLopt                besser82 
SDL_image            jwrdegoede limb moezroy 
WindowMaker          sham1 
abc                  brouhaha jjames somlo 
audiofile            ajax alexl caillon caolanm limb rhughes rstrode ssp 
binutils             aoliva jakub jankratochvil law mcermak nickc 
cfitsio              orion sergiopr 
community-mysql      hhorak ljavorsk mmuzila mschorm 
compat-guile18       jskarvad limb mlichvar tkorbar 
condor               bbockelm bcotton eerlands matt matyas stevetraylen tstclair ttheisen valtri 
conky-manager        moceap 
czmq                 denisarnaud jpo 
eb                   moceap petersen 
esc                  jmagne 
ettercap             limb 
fcl                  rmattes thofmann 
fortune-mod          sheltren shlomif 
freeradius           cipherboy nkondras rharwood 
glib2                alexl caillon caolanm mbarnes mclasen rhughes rstrode rtcm ssp 
gnokii               limb robert snirkel 
gpgme                fkluknav ignatenkobrain isimluk rdieter 
gpick                luya 
gupnp-dlna           kalev zeenix 
hdf                  orion sagitter 
jq                   hguemar lon 
k3guitune            dtimms 
kdebase3             jreznik kkofler rdieter than 
kdegames3            kkofler rdieter than 
kdepim3              jreznik ovasik rdieter than 
kicad                avigne coremodule lkundrak stevenfalco tnorth 
koffice-kivio        kkofler rdieter 
komparator           nbecker 
laszip               devrim neteler smani 
levmar               aalvarez brouhaha 
libXcm               cicku kwizart 
libburn              cwickert fkluknav hhorak pcahyna robert 
libcommuni           atim 
libdkimpp            dfateyev 
libdxfrw             hobbes1069 spot 
libeXosip2           nucleo 
libisoburn           fkluknav hhorak robert 
libkkc               ueno 
libminc              ignatenkobrain 
liboping             fab lkundrak 
libosip2             nucleo 
libprelude           fab totol 
librfid              kushal 
lutok                jmmv 
mcpp                 kmatsui mef 
mingw-qt5-qt3d       epienbro smani 
mingw-qt5-qtbase     epienbro smani 
mingw-qt5-qtdeclarative epienbro smani 
mingw-qt5-qttools    epienbro smani 
mod_wsgi             jdornak jkaluza jorton lmacken mrunge 
mongo-c-driver       remi 
ncview               deji orion 
nightview            lkundrak 
openjade             ovasik 
openscap             evgenyz isimluk jcerny matyc mmarhefk pvrabec vpolasek wsato 
pam_mount            lupinix steve till 
pam_yubico           nb ohaessler wzzrd 
perl-SDL             jwrdegoede 
pinentry             branto jjelen rdieter 
plotmm               orphan 
python2.7            churchyard cstratak torsava vstinner 
qucs                 avigne jskarvad 
qwtpolar             volter 
rarian               nonamedotc 
rb_libtorrent        fale mooninite 
rrdtool              jskarvad 
scap-workbench       evgenyz jcerny matyc mbarabas mlysonek mmarhefk pvrabec wsato 
scipy                cstratak jspaleta nforro orion tomspur ttomecek 
sofia-sip            orphan 
sqlite2              spot 
stp                  amdunn jjames 
suitesparse          deji jkastner mjakubicek nphilipp orion 
sylfilter            aarem 
texlive-base         spot 
tracker              amigadave deji garnacho ignatenkobrain mcrha rishi 
tracker-miners       garnacho kalev rishi 
usnic-tools          honli 
vanessa_logger       hubbitus 
verbiste             cicku icon tartare 
woff2                erack tpopela 
xbsql                spot 
xdotool              ohaessler orion slankes 
xeus                 qulogic 
xmms                 spot 
yaz                  cicku guidograzioli 
zinnia               liangsuilong pwu 
zvbi                 buc jwrdegoede mchehab 
 
Packages by maintainer: 
aalvarez   levmar 
aarem      sylfilter 
ajax       audiofile 
alexl      audiofile glib2 
amdunn     stp 
amigadave  tracker 
aoliva     binutils 
atim       libcommuni 
avigne     kicad qucs 
bbockelm   condor 
bcotton    condor 
besser82   NLopt 
branto     pinentry 
brouhaha   abc levmar 
buc        zvbi 
caillon    audiofile glib2 
caolanm    audiofile glib2 
churchyard python2.7 
cicku      libXcm verbiste yaz 
cipherboy  freeradius 
coremodule kicad 
cstratak   python2.7 scipy 
cwickert   libburn 
deji       ncview suitesparse tracker 
denisarnaud czmq 
devrim     laszip 
dfateyev   libdkimpp 
dtimms     k3guitune 
eerlands   condor 
epienbro   mingw-qt5-qt3d mingw-qt5-qtbase mingw-qt5-qtdeclarative mingw-qt5-qttools 
erack      woff2 
evgenyz    openscap scap-workbench 
fab        liboping libprelude 
fale       rb_libtorrent 
fkluknav   gpgme libburn libisoburn 
garnacho   tracker tracker-miners 
guidograzioli yaz 
hguemar    jq 
hhorak     community-mysql libburn libisoburn 
hobbes1069 libdxfrw 
honli      usnic-tools 
hubbitus   vanessa_logger 
icon       verbiste 
ignatenkobrain gpgme libminc tracker 
isimluk    gpgme openscap 
jakub      binutils 
jankratochvil binutils 
jcerny     openscap scap-workbench 
jdornak    mod_wsgi 
jjames     abc stp 
jjelen     pinentry 
jkaluza    mod_wsgi 
jkastner   suitesparse 
jmagne     esc 
jmmv       lutok 
jorton     mod_wsgi 
jpo        czmq 
jreznik    kdebase3 kdepim3 
jskarvad   compat-guile18 qucs rrdtool 
jspaleta   scipy 
jwrdegoede SDL_image perl-SDL zvbi 
kalev      gupnp-dlna tracker-miners 
kkofler    kdebase3 kdegames3 koffice-kivio 
kmatsui    mcpp 
kushal     librfid 
kwizart    libXcm 
law        binutils 
liangsuilong zinnia 
limb       Io-language SDL_image audiofile compat-guile18 ettercap gnokii 
ljavorsk   community-mysql 
lkundrak   kicad liboping nightview 
lmacken    mod_wsgi 
lon        jq 
lupinix    pam_mount 
luya       gpick 
matt       condor 
matyas     condor 
matyc      openscap scap-workbench 
mbarabas   scap-workbench 
mbarnes    glib2 
mcermak    binutils 
mchehab    zvbi 
mclasen    glib2 
mcrha      tracker 
mef        mcpp 
mjakubicek suitesparse 
mlichvar   compat-guile18 
mlysonek   scap-workbench 
mmarhefk   openscap scap-workbench 
mmuzila    community-mysql 
moceap     conky-manager eb 
moezroy    SDL_image 
mooninite  rb_libtorrent 
mrunge     mod_wsgi 
mschorm    community-mysql 
nb         pam_yubico 
nbecker    komparator 
neteler    laszip 
nforro     scipy 
nickc      binutils 
nkondras   freeradius 
nonamedotc rarian 
nphilipp   suitesparse 
nucleo     libeXosip2 libosip2 
ohaessler  pam_yubico xdotool 
orion      cfitsio hdf ncview scipy suitesparse xdotool 
orphan     plotmm sofia-sip 
ovasik     kdepim3 openjade 
pcahyna    libburn 
petersen   eb 
pvrabec    openscap scap-workbench 
pwu        zinnia 
qulogic    xeus 
rdieter    gpgme kdebase3 kdegames3 kdepim3 koffice-kivio pinentry 
remi       mongo-c-driver 
rharwood   freeradius 
rhughes    audiofile glib2 
rishi      tracker tracker-miners 
rmattes    fcl 
robert     gnokii libburn libisoburn 
rstrode    audiofile glib2 
rtcm       glib2 
sagitter   hdf 
sergiopr   cfitsio 
sham1      WindowMaker 
sheltren   fortune-mod 
shlomif    fortune-mod 
slankes    xdotool 
smani      laszip mingw-qt5-qt3d mingw-qt5-qtbase mingw-qt5-qtdeclarative mingw-qt5-qttools 
snirkel    gnokii 
somlo      abc 
spot       libdxfrw sqlite2 texlive-base xbsql xmms 
ssp        audiofile glib2 
steve      pam_mount 
stevenfalco kicad 
stevetraylen condor 
tartare    verbiste 
than       kdebase3 kdegames3 kdepim3 
thofmann   fcl 
till       pam_mount 
tkorbar    compat-guile18 
tnorth     kicad 
tomspur    scipy 
torsava    python2.7 
totol      libprelude 
tpopela    woff2 
tstclair   condor 
ttheisen   condor 
ttomecek   scipy 
ueno       libkkc 
valtri     condor 
volter     qwtpolar 
vpolasek   openscap 
vstinner   python2.7 
wsato      openscap scap-workbench 
wzzrd      pam_yubico 
zeenix     gupnp-dlna


-- 
Regards,

Charalampos Stratakis
Software Engineer
Python Maintenance Team, Red Hat
_______________________________________________
devel mailing list -- devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe send an email to devel-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Fedora Code of Conduct: https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/project/code-of-conduct/
List Guidelines: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines
List Archives: https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Do not reply to spam on the list, report it: https://pagure.io/fedora-infrastructure




[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[Index of Archives]     [Fedora Announce]     [Fedora Users]     [Fedora Kernel]     [Fedora Testing]     [Fedora Formulas]     [Fedora PHP Devel]     [Kernel Development]     [Fedora Legacy]     [Fedora Maintainers]     [Fedora Desktop]     [PAM]     [Red Hat Development]     [Gimp]     [Yosemite News]

  Powered by Linux