On Thu, 04 Mar 2004 10:36:36 -0500, Toshio wrote: > I've been going on the assumption that everything on the > QAChecklist is mandatory. Mandatory as in "it's mandatory to know that the list exists". ;) Actually, it's a framework. Something to start with. Important for a community project like fedora.us, which has had to avoid repeating mistakes and which has had (and still has) to fill the repository with a reliable base set of packages which other packages can depend on. An attempt at collecting things that should be verified by those who review packages. Starting with security considerations, plus things that have been encountered in early package requests and which have been discussed on the mailing list. That's why things like "License instead of Copyright" are on that list, too. The "Copyright" tag is deprecated, but it still builds fine and appears as "License" in the binary rpm. Not a major issue. And if a package were fine except for using "Copyright" tag instead if "License", would you request an update? It's mandatory to feel good about a package if you approve it. --
