Blame me for pushing Echo through FESCO. After following suggestion for submitting it to FESCO, I was a bit surprised that icon set was accepted. Were it rejected, we will not have to deal with current issue. In one part we'd withdraw Echo while taking a hit from outside for once again not include it; in other part we keep, taking a hit for having some incomplete set. That is dilemma which basically means choosing a poison. It reminds PackageKit case that was pushed as 0.1 release which some incomplete functions. Granted, it has not as visible as Echo. It is up to the leader who has a final sentence. Máirín Duffy a écrit : > Here's some of that feedback. There are other screenshots at > the bottom of the page I wanted to do the full critique on, > but after spending some hours doing the critique that is > complete there, I felt that what is there sufficiently and > objectively demonstrates that Echo is not ready to be a > default icon set: > > https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Duffy/EchoCritiqueF10 > Martin covered most issues, here is mine: Gedit: * - Gnome version of new file has a too bright star. * - Save icon can a matter of debate, Gnome version looks like a portable cd player. Echo version rendering issue will be addressed. * - Other Echo icons were from early version that need to be changed Gimp * Help and Reset are not Echo icons. System Hardware * Keyboard: actually a wrong symlink version because that icon was initially intended for preferences-desktop-keyboard-shortcut. I have prepared a new version of based on your suggestion minus letters along along with revamped input-keyboard I am uploading shortly.[1] * Palm: was before the new guideline, intended to fix that. * Firefox and Thunderbird: Actually Thunderbird perspective appears to match Echo version. When it comes to circular, only shadows are dealt. * That paint icon: does not come by default in panel. Additional icons * From which size of icons those blurriness come from? Luya - Nuts enough to have five different icons theme on desktop. Reference --------------- http://luya.fedorapeople.org/echo/applications/
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ Fedora-art-list mailing list Fedora-art-list@xxxxxxxxxx http://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-art-list
