Just my opinion: Well the icons look good indeed.. but i wonder if he is capable of making echo icons in the echo color theme (i find the verry hard to do) and judging from his current icons that have a ton of gradients inside them i think he will need to learn a lot more to make echo icons in the echo theme.. but it would be a gread addition to the art team if he would join. The biggest issue with those icons (speaking for myself now) is that it's not hard to imitate a existing icon and just "recreate" it in a slightly different style isn't the best thing.. having the imagination to come up with icons that are already telling you what you can expect is the important thing (example the echo settings icon is just telling that you are about to change some settings when you click it. you just need people for the echo icon theme that can do this. IF this person can(?) do that than i would deffinately ask him to join. Hope this helps. _______________________________________________ Fedora-art-list mailing list Fedora-art-list@xxxxxxxxxx http://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-art-list
