Hi Andreas, Andreas Färber <afaerber@xxxxxxx> writes: > Am 15.05.2017 um 10:16 schrieb Neil Armstrong: [...] >> >> It's not perfect, but now it's done, live with it, this has already been discussed. > > No. > > Copy&pasting your comment N times does not make it any more valid. My > files, my rules - I insist on vega-s95, gxbb and gx, which you guys > refactored out from my gxbb, to be tidy. hmm, "my files, my rules, ... my gxbb" Very interesting perspective, but sorry, these do not belong to you. They belong to the kernel community. You can insist if you like, but we do not make decisions just because someone says "mine". Again, the confrontaional tone is not helpful to the dialogue. [...] >> >> Well, this is why we have 7 rc releases after the merge window... > > If Kevin is the maintainer, then he needs to carefully review patches. Thank you for implying that I don't carefully review patches. You're winning me over. :( Please see my reply to the cover letter as to why this kind of thing has not been on my priority list of things I look for during review. > It is not my job to review all patches when BayLibre gets paid for it! You have no idea who is getting paid for what kind of work, so please don't make decisions about what you review based on your assumptions. [...] > I will also remind that I was forced to clean up the node order in ALL > exynos5250 .dts files before I could get my new exynos5250-spring.dts > merged, so I have zero understanding about these "churn" and "live with > it" comments here. The same rules need to apply to all It's a nice ideal that the same rules would apply to all, and in some areas of the kernel, it may be true. However, in actual practice, across the variety of kernel subsystems and platforms, there are in fact a rather large variety of "rules" with a huge amount of discretion left up to the maintainers. While that is a point of endless frustration for some (many?) it's also part of what makes the kernel community healthy, vibrant and still alive. Look, you convinced me based on sound technical arguments, good code, well written changelogs and persistence, even in spite of your accusatory tone and insinuations. For future reference, I'd be much happier to review without the latter. Thanks, Kevin -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe devicetree" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
