Hi, On 12/09/2013 12:10 PM, srinivas kandagatla wrote:
Hi Chen, Good to know that Allwinner uses gmac. On ST SoC, we have very similar requirements, before we merge any of these changes I think we need to come up with common way to solve both Allwinner and ST SOCs use cases. I have already posted few patches on to net-dev http://lkml.org/lkml/2013/11/12/243 to add Glue driver on top of stmmac driver. There are few reasons for the way I have done it. 1> I did not want to modify gmac driver in any sense to when a new SOC support is added. 2> As the SOC specific glue logic sits on top of standard GMAC IP, it makes sense to represent it proper harware hierarchy.
On top often is not the correct term / how things are done in practice. Most of the time the glue are modifications to the ip block, iow in hardware they are not nested / hierarchical at all. We've had similar constructs for ahci platform drivers and there we are actively trying to move away from the whole nested platform devices as that has various issues: 1) It is wrong / does not reflect reality 2) It breaks deferred probing which is often used on SOCs I actually think Wens' approach using a SOC specific init function in platform data is sound, and this is also used a lot else where. As for using the nested approach elsewhere, I only know about AHCI platform driver doing that, and there we are actively trying to move away from it. Now reading this has also made me take a closer look at wens' patch for this. Wens, I see that you directly modify registers in the ccm that is a big no-no instead you should add a helper function to sunxi-clk.c and use that, see ie: https://bitbucket.org/emiliolopez/linux/commits/2b95847d9aa4aa13317dd7358ffcbd951dcb5eff?at=master Giuseppe, I get the feeling the 0x148 registers st-gmac is using is the same story, but I could be wrong. One important reason why accessing regs like this directly is a big no no is because it is impossible to do proper locking between multiple users, so 2 users doing read / modify / write could end up racing. So accesses to such registers should always happen through a single driver. Regards, Hans -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe devicetree" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
