On Thu, 12 Sep 2013, Santosh Shilimkar wrote:
> On Thursday 12 September 2013 08:26 PM, Thomas Gleixner wrote:
> > Let me summarize:
> >
> > - GIC supports up to 160 interrupts
> >
> > - CROSSBAR supports up to 250 interrupts
> >
> > - CROSSBAR routes up to 160 out of 250 interrupts to the GIC ones
> >
> > - Drivers request a CROSSBAR interrupt number which must be mapped
> > to some arbitrary available GIC irq number
> >
> Correct.
>
> > So basically the CROSSBAR mechanism is pretty much the same as MSI[X]
> > just in a different flavour and with a different set of semantics and
> > limitations, i.e. poor mans MSI[X] with a new level of bogosity.
> >
> > So if CROSSBAR is going to be the new fangled SoC MSI[X] long term
> > equivalent then you better provide some infrastructure for that and
> > make the drivers ready to use it. Maybe check with the PCI/MSI folks
> > to share some of the interfaces.
> >
> > If that whole thing is another onetime HW designers wet dream, then
> > please go back to the limited but completely functional (Who is going
> > to use more than 160 peripheral interrupts????) device tree model. I
> > really have no interest to support hardware designer brain farts.
> >
> Thanks for clear NAK for irqchip approach. I should have looped you
> in the discussion where I was also suggesting against the irqchip
> approach. We will try to look at MSI stuff but if its get too
> complicated am going to fall-back to the initial probe based
> approach to achieve the functionality.
Before you dig into MSI, lets talk about irq domains first.
GIC implements a legacy irq domain, i.e. a linear domain of all
possible GIC interrupts with a 1:1 mapping.
So why can't you make use of irq domains and have the whole routing
business implemented sanely?
What's needed is in gic_init_bases():
if (of_property_read(node, "routable_irqs", &nr_routable_irqs) {
irq_domain_add_legacy(nr_gic_irqs);
} else {
irq_domain_add_legacy(nr_per_cpu_irqs);
irq_domain_add_linear(nr_routable_irqs);
}
Now that separate domain has an xlate function which grabs a free GIC
irq from a bitmap and returns the hardware irq number in the gic
space. The map/unmap callbacks take care of setting up / tearing down
the route in the crossbar.
Thoughts?
Thanks,
tglx
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe devicetree" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
