Hi Wyll, Not a rgw developer but from my test and what I understood from the code the Put/GetBucketReplication create/read replication rule specific to a bucket and does not read the one that you globally created. For instance here is a rule that I created via the PutBucketReplication (with `aws s3api put-bucket-replication`) which is not visible If I list all the sync group globally (so without the --bucket=conflict in my case): ``` [15:52][root@rgwmulti2-rgw2 (arthur_dev:ceph/rgwmulti2/traefik*1) ~]# radosgw-admin sync group get --bucket=conflict [ { "key": "s3-bucket-replication:disabled", "val": { "id": "s3-bucket-replication:disabled", "data_flow": {}, "pipes": [], "status": "allowed" } }, { "key": "s3-bucket-replication:enabled", "val": { "id": "s3-bucket-replication:enabled", "data_flow": {}, "pipes": [ { "id": "replication", "source": { "bucket": "*", "zones": [ "*" ] }, "dest": { "bucket": "conflict", "zones": [ "*" ] }, "params": { "source": { "filter": { "tags": [] } }, "dest": {}, "priority": 0, "mode": "user", "user": "conflict" } } ], "status": "enabled" } } ] ``` The setup that I tested with some success is basically the one from the doc `Two Zones, Complete Mirror` but instead I just don't enable the replication just leaving it as `allowed` and thus the users would just enable the replication themselves with the s3 API. Cheers, -- Arthur Outhenin-Chalandre On 4/26/22 17:14, Wyll Ingersoll wrote: > > In Pacific (16.2.7) can the radosgw multisite configuration policies be > manipulated with the AWS S3 APIs such as GetBucketReplication, > PutBucketReplication? > > I have multisite replication working on a per-bucket basis that was set > up using the radosgw-admin (sync group *** commands). Can these > policies be accessed in any way using the actual S3 REST API? > > The documentation (https://docs.ceph.com/en/pacific/radosgw/s3/ > <https://docs.ceph.com/en/pacific/radosgw/s3/>) seems to indicate that > the "Bucket Replication" API is partially supported (across zones > only). When I use the "GetBucketReplication" API on a bucket that is > configured with a multisite sync group and pipe, it does not return any > policy data. > > If I use the raw S3 API, I see the following result when I use the > boto3.get_bucket_replication(bucket='bucket-1'): > > { > > "ResponseMetadata": { > > "RequestId": "tx00000cdf1db80cb3fda06-006268085f-247a6fc4-keeper-1", > > "HostId": "", > > "HTTPStatusCode": 200, > > "HTTPHeaders": { > > "x-amz-request-id": > "tx00000cdf1db80cb3fda06-006268085f-247a6fc4-keeper-1", > > "content-type": "application/xml", > > "content-length": "152", > > "date": "Tue, 26 Apr 2022 14:57:35 GMT", > > "connection": "Keep-Alive" > > }, > > "RetryAttempts": 0 > > }, > > "ReplicationConfiguration": { > > "Role": "" > > } > > } > > > > > thanks, > Wyllys Ingersoll _______________________________________________ Dev mailing list -- dev@xxxxxxx To unsubscribe send an email to dev-leave@xxxxxxx