On 5/23/22 7:13 PM, Yu Kuai wrote: > ? 2022/05/23 23:25, Jan Kara ??: >> On Mon 23-05-22 06:36:58, Jens Axboe wrote: >>> On 5/23/22 2:59 AM, Jan Kara wrote: >>>> On Mon 23-05-22 09:10:38, yukuai (C) wrote: >>>>> ? 2022/05/21 20:21, Jens Axboe ??: >>>>>> On 5/21/22 1:22 AM, yukuai (C) wrote: >>>>>>> ? 2022/05/14 17:29, yukuai (C) ??: >>>>>>>> ? 2022/05/05 9:00, yukuai (C) ??: >>>>>>>>> Hi, Paolo >>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>> Can you take a look at this patchset? It has been quite a long time >>>>>>>>> since we spotted this problem... >>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>> >>>>>>>> friendly ping ... >>>>>>> friendly ping ... >>>>>> >>>>>> I can't speak for Paolo, but I've mentioned before that the majority >>>>>> of your messages end up in my spam. That's still the case, in fact >>>>>> I just marked maybe 10 of them as not spam. >>>>>> >>>>>> You really need to get this issued sorted out, or you will continue >>>>>> to have patches ignore because folks may simply not see them. >>>>>> >>>>> Hi, >>>>> >>>>> Thanks for your notice. >>>>> >>>>> Is it just me or do you see someone else's messages from *huawei.com >>>>> end up in spam? I tried to seek help from our IT support, however, they >>>>> didn't find anything unusual... >>>> >>>> So actually I have noticed that a lot of (valid) email from huawei.com (not >>>> just you) ends up in the spam mailbox. For me direct messages usually pass >>>> (likely matching SPF records for originating mail server save the email >>>> from going to spam) but messages going through mailing lists are flagged as >>>> spam because the emails are missing valid DKIM signature but huawei.com >>>> DMARC config says there should be DKIM signature (even direct messages are >>>> missing DKIM so this does not seem as a mailing list configuration issue). >>>> So this seems as some misconfiguration of the mails on huawei.com side >>>> (likely missing DKIM signing of outgoing email). >>> >>> SPF/DKIM was indeed a problem earlier for yukaui patches, but I don't >>> see that anymore. Maybe it's still an issue for some emails, from them >>> or Huawei in general? >> >> Hum, for me all emails from Huawei I've received even today fail the DKIM >> check. After some more digging there is interesting inconsistency in DMARC >> configuration for huawei.com domain. There is DMARC record for huawei.com >> like: >> >> huawei.com. 600 IN TXT "v=DMARC1;p=none;rua=mailto:dmarc@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx"; >> >> which means no DKIM is required but _dmarc.huawei.com has: >> >> _dmarc.huawei.com. 600 IN TXT "v=DMARC1;p=quarantine;ruf=mailto:dmarc@xxxxxxxxxx;rua=mailto:dmarc@xxxxxxxxxx"; >> >> which says that DKIM is required. I guess this inconsistency may be the >> reason why there are problems with DKIM validation for senders from >> huawei.com. Yu Kuai, can you perhaps take this to your IT support to fix >> this? Either make sure huawei.com emails get properly signed with DKIM or >> remove the 'quarantine' record from _dmarc.huawei.com. Thanks! > Of course, I'll try to contact our IT support. I second that, pretty much every email has been going into spam since, I guess you just had a few lucky ones. Looks like Jan is right, it's a server side configuration error that's causing this, and it's still happening -- Jens Axboe
