Blocked ops after change from filestore on HDD to bluestore on SDD

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



Hi,

TL;DR: In my Ceph clusters I replaced all OSDs from HDDs of several brands and models with Samsung 860 Pro SSDs and used the opportunity to switch from filestore to bluestore. Now I'm seeing blocked ops in Ceph and file system freezes inside VMs. Any suggestions?


I have two Proxmox clusters for virtualization which use Ceph on HDDs as backend storage for VMs. About half a year ago I had to increase the pool size and used the occasion to switch from filestore to bluestore. That was when trouble started. Both clusters showed blocked ops that caused freezes inside VMs which needed a reboot to function properly again. I wasn't able to identify the cause of the blocking ops but I blamed the low performance of the HDDs. It was also the time when patches for Spectre/Meltdown were released. Kernel 4.13.x didn't show the behavior while kernel 4.15.x did. After several weeks of debugging the workaround was to go back to filestore.

Today I replace all HDDs with brand new Samsung 860 Pro SSDs and switched to bluestore again (on one cluster). And… the blocked ops reappeared. I am out of ideas about the cause.

Any idea why bluestore is so much more demanding on the storage devices compared to filestore?

Before switching back to filestore do you have any suggestions for debugging? Anything special to check for in the network?

The clusters are both connected via 10GbE (MTU 9000) and are only lightly loaded (15 VMs on the first, 6 VMs on the second). Each host has 3 SSDs and 64GB memory.

"rados bench" gives decent results for 4M block size but 4K block size triggers blocked ops (and only finishes after I restart the OSD with the blocked ops). Results below.


Thanks,

	Uwe




Results from "rados bench" runs with 4K block size when the cluster didn't block:

root@px-hotel-cluster:~# rados bench -p scbench 60 write -b 4K -t 16 --no-cleanup
hints = 1
Maintaining 16 concurrent writes of 4096 bytes to objects of size 4096 for up to 60 seconds or 0 objects
Object prefix: benchmark_data_px-hotel-cluster_3814550
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
    0       0         0         0         0         0           -           0
    1      16      2338      2322   9.06888   9.07031   0.0068972   0.0068597
    2      16      4631      4615   9.01238   8.95703   0.0076618  0.00692027
    3      16      6936      6920   9.00928   9.00391   0.0066511  0.00692966
    4      16      9173      9157   8.94133   8.73828  0.00416256  0.00698071
    5      16     11535     11519   8.99821   9.22656  0.00799875  0.00693842
    6      16     13892     13876   9.03287   9.20703  0.00688782  0.00691459
    7      15     16173     16158   9.01578   8.91406  0.00791589  0.00692736
    8      16     18406     18390   8.97854   8.71875  0.00745151  0.00695723
    9      16     20681     20665   8.96822   8.88672   0.0072881  0.00696475
   10      16     23037     23021   8.99163   9.20312  0.00728763   0.0069473
   11      16     24261     24245   8.60882   4.78125  0.00502342  0.00725673
   12      16     25420     25404   8.26863   4.52734  0.00443917  0.00750865
   13      16     27347     27331   8.21154   7.52734  0.00670819  0.00760455
   14      16     28750     28734   8.01642   5.48047  0.00617038  0.00779322
   15      16     30222     30206    7.8653      5.75  0.00700398  0.00794209
   16      16     32180     32164    7.8517   7.64844  0.00704785   0.0079573
   17      16     34527     34511   7.92907   9.16797  0.00582831  0.00788017
   18      15     36969     36954   8.01868   9.54297  0.00635168  0.00779228
   19      16     39059     39043   8.02609   8.16016  0.00622597  0.00778436
2019-02-26 21:55:41.623245 min lat: 0.00337595 max lat: 0.431158 avg lat: 0.00779143
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   20      16     41079     41063   8.01928   7.89062  0.00649895  0.00779143
   21      16     43076     43060   8.00878   7.80078  0.00726145  0.00780128
   22      16     45433     45417   8.06321   9.20703  0.00455727  0.00774944
   23      16     47763     47747   8.10832   9.10156  0.00582818  0.00770599
   24      16     50079     50063   8.14738   9.04688   0.0051125  0.00766894
   25      16     52477     52461   8.19614   9.36719  0.00537575  0.00762343
   26      16     54895     54879   8.24415   9.44531  0.00573134  0.00757909
   27      16     57276     57260   8.28325   9.30078  0.00576683  0.00754383
   28      16     59487     59471   8.29585   8.63672  0.00651535  0.00753232
   29      16     61948     61932   8.34125   9.61328  0.00499461  0.00749048
   30      16     64289     64273   8.36799   9.14453  0.00735917  0.00746708
   31      16     66645     66629    8.3949   9.20312  0.00644432  0.00744233
   32      16     68926     68910   8.41098   8.91016  0.00545702   0.0074289
   33      16     71257     71241     8.432   9.10547  0.00505016  0.00741037
   34      16     73668     73652   8.46097   9.41797  0.00432774  0.00738525
   35      16     76088     76072   8.48929   9.45312  0.00514377  0.00736052
   36      16     78340     78324   8.49781   8.79688  0.00623798  0.00735318
   37      16     79702     79686   8.41192   5.32031  0.00586925  0.00742791
   38      16     82048     82032   8.43169   9.16406  0.00631341  0.00741101
   39      16     84574     84558   8.46848   9.86719  0.00457312   0.0073788
2019-02-26 21:56:01.625257 min lat: 0.00337595 max lat: 0.431158 avg lat: 0.00735446
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   40      16     87027     87011    8.4963   9.58203  0.00483967  0.00735446
   41      16     89363     89347    8.5116     9.125  0.00689418  0.00734112
   42      16     91532     91516   8.51066   8.47266  0.00589121  0.00734207
   43      16     94011     93995   8.53791   9.68359  0.00687577  0.00731853
   44      16     96510     96494   8.56571   9.76172  0.00554477  0.00729513
   45      16     98825     98809   8.57629   9.04297  0.00659778  0.00728593
   46      16    101096    101080   8.58269   8.87109  0.00645024  0.00728041
   47      16    103334    103318   8.58606   8.74219  0.00533782  0.00727755
   48      16    105796    105780   8.60752   9.61719  0.00481175  0.00725942
   49      16    108209    108193    8.6242   9.42578  0.00665163  0.00724555
   50      16    110557    110541   8.63514   9.17188  0.00514146   0.0072366
   51      16    112799    112783   8.63753   8.75781  0.00542164  0.00723403
   52      16    115145    115129   8.64764   9.16406   0.0078739   0.0072261
   53      16    117599    117583   8.66532   9.58594  0.00636182  0.00721115
   54      16    119951    119935   8.67497    9.1875  0.00902746  0.00720322
   55      16    122231    122215   8.67916   8.90625  0.00769823  0.00719975
   56      16    124473    124457   8.68055   8.75781  0.00455414  0.00719853
   57      16    126845    126829    8.6908   9.26562  0.00440477  0.00719023
   58      16    129172    129156   8.69766   9.08984    0.014724  0.00718433
   59      16    130642    130626   8.64756   5.74219   0.0044018   0.0072242
2019-02-26 21:56:21.627245 min lat: 0.00337595 max lat: 0.431158 avg lat: 0.00722993
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   60      13    132775    132762   8.64248   8.34375   0.0074357  0.00722993
Total time run:         60.006703
Total writes made:      132775
Write size:             4096
Object size:            4096
Bandwidth (MB/sec):     8.64324
Stddev Bandwidth:       1.24153
Max bandwidth (MB/sec): 9.86719
Min bandwidth (MB/sec): 4.52734
Average IOPS:           2212
Stddev IOPS:            317
Max IOPS:               2526
Min IOPS:               1159
Average Latency(s):     0.00723007
Stddev Latency(s):      0.00965629
Max latency(s):         0.431158
Min latency(s):         0.00337595

root@px-hotel-cluster:~# rados bench -p scbench 60 seq -t 16 --no-cleanup
hints = 1
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
    0       0         0         0         0         0           -           0
    1      15     25546     25531   99.7129   99.7305  0.00038738 0.000617037
    2      15     51245     51230   100.043   100.387 0.000679383 0.000614879
    3      15     77097     77082   100.353   100.984 0.000649252 0.000613069
    4      16    102482    102466   100.051   99.1562 0.000665031 0.000615048
    5      16    127877    127861   99.8788   99.1992   0.0003609 0.000616109
Total time run:       5.189528
Total reads made:     132775
Read size:            4096
Object size:          4096
Bandwidth (MB/sec):   99.9421
Average IOPS:         25585
Stddev IOPS:          201
Max IOPS:             25852
Min IOPS:             25384
Average Latency(s):   0.000615755
Max latency(s):       0.00516975
Min latency(s):       0.000300567

root@px-hotel-cluster:~# rados bench -p scbench 60 rand -t 16 --no-cleanup
hints = 1
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
    0       0         0         0         0         0           -           0
    1      16     29609     29593   115.579   115.598 0.000356415   0.0005319
    2      16     58715     58699    114.63   113.695 0.000685151 0.000536463
    3      15     88167     88152   114.765   115.051 0.000372257 0.000535853
    4      15    117488    117473   114.705   114.535  0.00047013 0.000536184
    5      15    146694    146679   114.579   114.086  0.00037833 0.000536823
    6      16    176406    176390   114.824   116.059 0.000659678 0.000535637
    7      15    205080    205065   114.421   112.012  0.00028265 0.000537569
    8      15    235437    235422   114.939   118.582 0.000438279 0.000535161
    9      15    264395    264380   114.736   113.117 0.000619314 0.000536149
   10      15    293705    293690    114.71   114.492  0.00050762 0.000536255
   11      15    322550    322535   114.524   112.676  0.00116935 0.000537162
   12      15    350283    350268   114.007   108.332 0.000482695 0.000539653
   13      15    380550    380535   114.331    118.23 0.000637042 0.000538136
   14      15    409882    409867   114.348   114.578 0.000340766 0.000538077
   15      15    439190    439175   114.357   114.484 0.000901077 0.000538053
   16      16    468430    468414   114.347   114.215 0.000526489 0.000538119
   17      15    498201    498186   114.461   116.297  0.00039584 0.000537558
   18      15    527448    527433   114.449   114.246 0.000561086 0.000537584
   19      16    557524    557508   114.608    117.48 0.000459305 0.000536828
2019-02-26 21:57:29.158335 min lat: 0.000193689 max lat: 0.00471296 avg lat: 0.000536229
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   20      15    587514    587499   114.734   117.152 0.000298343 0.000536229
   21      16    615970    615954   114.563   111.152 0.000617898 0.000537056
   22      16    646448    646432   114.767   119.055 0.000365562 0.000536103
   23      15    676857    676842   114.941   118.789  0.00053347 0.000535283
   24      16    707108    707092   115.075   118.164 0.000489048  0.00053466
   25      15    735298    735283   114.876   110.121 0.000879961 0.000535606
   26      16    763299    763283   114.664   109.375 0.000893751  0.00053662
   27      15    792847    792832   114.692   115.426 0.000289513 0.000536496
   28      15    822380    822365   114.716   115.363 0.000363185 0.000536393
   29      15    851806    851791   114.723   114.945 0.000400721  0.00053637
   30      15    882240    882225   114.862   118.883 0.000323953 0.000535728
   31      16    912697    912681   114.994   118.969 0.000584203  0.00053511
   32      16    942922    942906    115.09   118.066 0.000237542 0.000534669
   33      15    972480    972465   115.101   115.465 0.000304352 0.000534625
   34      15   1002004   1001989   115.107   115.328 0.000417205 0.000534598
   35      15   1031656   1031641   115.127   115.828 0.000731773 0.000534508
   36      15   1061794   1061779   115.199   117.727 0.000399053 0.000534167
   37      15   1090982   1090967   115.167   114.016 0.000273898 0.000534303
   38      15   1120932   1120917   115.215   116.992 0.000563786 0.000534085
   39      16   1151319   1151303   115.304   118.695 0.000584587 0.000533673
2019-02-26 21:57:49.160177 min lat: 0.000189357 max lat: 0.00551016 avg lat: 0.000533845
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   40      15   1180422   1180407   115.263   113.688 0.000266425 0.000533845
   41      16   1209042   1209026   115.178   111.793 0.000877275 0.000534238
   42      16   1238819   1238803   115.205   116.316 0.000268862 0.000534114
   43      15   1268209   1268194   115.195   114.809 0.000478607 0.000534166
   44      15   1298456   1298441   115.262   118.152 0.000371342 0.000533858
   45      15   1327611   1327596   115.232   113.887 0.000881212    0.000534
   46      15   1356842   1356827   115.209   114.184  0.00046055 0.000534112
   47      15   1386848   1386833   115.251   117.211 0.000775375 0.000533913
   48      15   1415035   1415020   115.143   110.105 0.000364161  0.00053442
   49      15   1444927   1444912   115.176   116.766 0.000374783  0.00053427
   50      15   1475316   1475301   115.247   118.707 0.000564861 0.000533942
   51      16   1504352   1504336   115.211   113.418  0.00068548 0.000534105
   52      15   1533646   1533631   115.196   114.434 0.000288343 0.000534174
   53      15   1564054   1564039   115.263   118.781 0.000587993  0.00053386
   54      15   1593366   1593351   115.249     114.5 0.000436205  0.00053392
   55      15   1622167   1622152   115.199   112.504 0.000601619 0.000534158
   56      15   1652256   1652241    115.24   117.535  0.00067666 0.000533963
   57      15   1681711   1681696   115.237   115.059 0.000723098 0.000533968
   58      15   1710686   1710671   115.201   113.184 0.000970663 0.000534127
   59      15   1740906   1740891   115.249   118.047 0.000314217 0.000533908
Total time run:       60.000464
Total reads made:     1770108
Read size:            4096
Object size:          4096
Bandwidth (MB/sec):   115.241
Average IOPS:         29501
Stddev IOPS:          666
Max IOPS:             30478
Min IOPS:             27733
Average Latency(s):   0.000533953
Max latency(s):       0.00551016
Min latency(s):       0.000189357

And results with 4M block size:

root@px-hotel-cluster:~# ceph osd pool create scbench 100 100
pool 'scbench' created

root@px-hotel-cluster:~# rados bench -p scbench 60 write -b 4M -t 16 --no-cleanup
hints = 1
Maintaining 16 concurrent writes of 4194304 bytes to objects of size 4194304 for up to 60 seconds or 0 objects
Object prefix: benchmark_data_px-hotel-cluster_3803595
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
    0       0         0         0         0         0           -           0
    1      16       121       105   419.981       420   0.0684363     0.14782
    2      16       231       215   429.951       440   0.0402411    0.141534
    3      16       365       349   465.275       536   0.0435463    0.134897
    4      16       470       454   453.944       420   0.0554416    0.135084
    5      16       568       552   441.544       392    0.233723    0.140098
    6      16       684       668   445.276       464   0.0357724    0.140952
    7      16       823       807   461.085       556    0.062224    0.138544
    8      16       926       910   454.942       412    0.263991    0.139367
    9      16      1044      1028   456.829       472    0.146897    0.138908
   10      16      1153      1137   454.741       436   0.0995426     0.13898
   11      16      1278      1262    458.85       500   0.0397514    0.138972
   12      16      1380      1364   454.609       408   0.0697221    0.138761
   13      16      1511      1495   459.942       524    0.090388    0.138845
   14      16      1621      1605   458.514       440    0.100218    0.138448
   15      16      1748      1732   461.809       508   0.0357433    0.138012
   16      16      1858      1842   460.443       440   0.0764942    0.138516
   17      16      1961      1945   457.591       412    0.209572    0.139726
   18      16      2064      2048   455.055       412    0.104463    0.139988
   19      16      2170      2154   453.418       424    0.165126    0.140337
2019-02-26 21:24:44.759567 min lat: 0.0227191 max lat: 0.318478 avg lat: 0.14015
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   20      16      2293      2277   455.344       492   0.0785952     0.14015
   21      16      2411      2395   456.134       472    0.137855    0.140047
   22      16      2527      2511   456.489       464    0.081168     0.13934
   23      16      2650      2634    458.03       492    0.127442    0.139296
   24      16      2765      2749    458.11       460   0.0591567    0.139316
   25      16      2870      2854   456.582       420   0.0341181    0.139131
   26      16      2996      2980   458.403       504   0.0631039     0.13931
   27      16      3110      3094   458.312       456   0.0528259    0.139285
   28      16      3217      3201   457.227       428    0.057046    0.139622
   29      16      3334      3318   457.596       468   0.0444768    0.139484
   30      16      3452      3436   458.074       472    0.167902    0.139238
   31      16      3556      3540   456.715       416   0.0392211     0.13946
   32      16      3669      3653   456.566       452    0.116063    0.139371
   33      16      3789      3773   457.274       480     0.10848    0.139689
   34      16      3900      3884   456.881       444   0.0312001    0.139837
   35      16      4005      3989   455.826       420   0.0999828    0.139968
   36      16      4126      4110   456.607       484   0.0748115    0.139842
   37      16      4233      4217   455.832       428    0.171641    0.140061
   38      16      4333      4317   454.361       400   0.0546583    0.140427
   39      16      4455      4439   455.222       488    0.109672    0.140391
2019-02-26 21:25:04.762404 min lat: 0.0219402 max lat: 0.453859 avg lat: 0.140093
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   40      16      4568      4552    455.14       452   0.0341032    0.140093
   41      16      4691      4675   456.037       492   0.0622903    0.140183
   42      16      4810      4794   456.511       476   0.0368881    0.139874
   43      16      4930      4914   457.056       480    0.136802    0.139648
   44      16      5043      5027   456.939       452   0.0941255    0.139592
   45      16      5168      5152   457.895       500   0.0859091    0.139689
   46      16      5275      5259   457.243       428   0.0553456    0.139781
   47      16      5384      5368    456.79       436   0.0559706    0.139848
   48      16      5494      5478   456.439       440   0.0504884    0.140001
   49      16      5608      5592   456.429       456   0.0936318    0.139992
   50      16      5736      5720   457.539       512    0.172677    0.139731
   51      16      5865      5849   458.683       516   0.0606197    0.139352
   52      16      5987      5971   459.246       488   0.0602065    0.139042
   53      16      6096      6080   458.806       436   0.0967087    0.139395
   54      16      6212      6196   458.901       464   0.0863546    0.139228
   55      16      6330      6314   459.138       472    0.143207    0.139147
   56      16      6439      6423   458.724       436    0.160516    0.139281
   57      16      6544      6528   458.044       420   0.0770203    0.139479
   58      16      6657      6641   457.938       452   0.0462132    0.139585
   59      16      6769      6753   457.769       448   0.0890968    0.139535
2019-02-26 21:25:24.765186 min lat: 0.0219402 max lat: 0.453859 avg lat: 0.139601
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   60      16      6885      6869   457.872       464   0.0683147    0.139601
Total time run:         60.064041
Total writes made:      6885
Write size:             4194304
Object size:            4194304
Bandwidth (MB/sec):     458.511
Stddev Bandwidth:       35.849
Max bandwidth (MB/sec): 556
Min bandwidth (MB/sec): 392
Average IOPS:           114
Stddev IOPS:            8
Max IOPS:               139
Min IOPS:               98
Average Latency(s):     0.139576
Stddev Latency(s):      0.0662593
Max latency(s):         0.453859
Min latency(s):         0.0219402

root@px-hotel-cluster:~# rados bench -p scbench 60 seq -t 16 --no-cleanup
hints = 1
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
    0       0         0         0         0         0           -           0
    1      16       384       368   1471.73      1472     0.01866   0.0415297
    2      16       696       680   1359.77      1248   0.0917004   0.0459489
    3      15      1048      1033   1376.92      1412   0.0166296   0.0452437
    4      16      1384      1368   1367.65      1340   0.0140827   0.0458988
    5      16      1775      1759   1406.88      1564   0.0225302    0.044743
    6      16      2128      2112   1407.71      1412   0.0298933   0.0448714
    7      16      2527      2511   1434.58      1596    0.020457   0.0439445
    8      15      2912      2897    1448.2      1544   0.0159675   0.0435627
    9      16      3313      3297   1465.05      1600   0.0186496   0.0429805
   10      16      3624      3608   1442.93      1244   0.0366258   0.0435085
   11      15      3942      3927    1427.7      1276   0.0179256   0.0442724
   12      16      4302      4286   1428.38      1436   0.0415135   0.0442627
   13      16      4714      4698   1445.25      1648   0.0256314   0.0436973
   14      16      5049      5033   1437.73      1340   0.0183511   0.0438648
   15      16      5397      5381   1434.67      1392   0.0467047   0.0439667
   16      16      5791      5775   1443.49      1576    0.103247   0.0437964
   17      16      6169      6153   1447.51      1512   0.0411054   0.0436606
   18      16      6574      6558   1457.08      1620   0.0331255   0.0433989
Total time run:       18.849876
Total reads made:     6885
Read size:            4194304
Object size:          4194304
Bandwidth (MB/sec):   1461.02
Average IOPS:         365
Stddev IOPS:          33
Max IOPS:             412
Min IOPS:             311
Average Latency(s):   0.043257
Max latency(s):       0.420441
Min latency(s):       0.0106036

root@px-hotel-cluster:~# rados bench -p scbench 60 rand -t 16 --no-cleanup
hints = 1
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
    0       0         0         0         0         0           -           0
    1      16       470       454   1815.73      1816   0.0512056   0.0339588
    2      16       933       917   1833.73      1852    0.012993   0.0339007
    3      16      1384      1368   1823.74      1804   0.0229874   0.0341975
    4      16      1824      1808   1807.74      1760   0.0315442   0.0346609
    5      16      2293      2277   1821.34      1876    0.018928   0.0343011
    6      16      2734      2718   1811.73      1764   0.0172553   0.0345841
    7      16      3188      3172   1812.31      1816   0.0526328   0.0346511
    8      16      3648      3632   1815.74      1840    0.064372   0.0346222
    9      16      4104      4088   1816.63      1824   0.0580501   0.0346048
   10      16      4556      4540   1815.75      1808   0.0203061   0.0346393
   11      15      5034      5019   1824.84      1916   0.0323724    0.034475
   12      16      5502      5486   1828.42      1868   0.0418273   0.0343747
   13      16      5961      5945   1828.98      1836   0.0910453   0.0343914
   14      16      6423      6407   1830.32      1848   0.0229763   0.0343634
   15      16      6889      6873   1832.56      1864   0.0106228   0.0342979
   16      15      7365      7350   1837.26      1908  0.00837461   0.0342174
   17      15      7847      7832   1842.58      1928   0.0247365   0.0341596
   18      15      8323      8308   1845.98      1904  0.00197862   0.0340899
   19      15      8760      8745   1840.82      1748   0.0185352   0.0341643
2019-02-26 21:26:56.730479 min lat: 0.00169505 max lat: 0.257525 avg lat: 0.0341765
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   20      16      9224      9208   1841.37      1852   0.0283496   0.0341765
   21      16      9683      9667   1841.09      1836   0.0476514   0.0341884
   22      16     10149     10133   1842.13      1864   0.0382981   0.0341645
   23      16     10601     10585   1840.63      1808   0.0399852   0.0341945
   24      15     11054     11039    1839.6      1816   0.0224427   0.0342213
   25      16     11515     11499    1839.6      1840    0.020452   0.0342026
   26      16     11995     11979   1842.68      1920   0.0703125    0.034164
   27      16     12464     12448   1843.91      1876   0.0693259   0.0341387
   28      15     12928     12913   1844.48      1860   0.0346587   0.0341312
   29      16     13392     13376   1844.73      1852   0.0227206   0.0341126
   30      16     13843     13827   1843.36      1804   0.0640094   0.0341546
   31      15     14296     14281   1842.47      1816   0.0945452   0.0341648
   32      15     14757     14742   1842.51      1844   0.0189832    0.034163
   33      16     15196     15180   1839.76      1752   0.0608944   0.0342256
   34      16     15632     15616   1836.94      1744   0.0829651   0.0342715
   35      15     16087     16072   1836.56      1824   0.0292455   0.0342801
   36      15     16549     16534   1836.87      1848   0.0245028    0.034283
   37      16     16988     16972   1834.57      1752   0.0799359   0.0343315
   38      15     17414     17399   1831.24      1708   0.0173303   0.0343958
   39      16     17871     17855   1831.04      1824   0.0402483   0.0343933
2019-02-26 21:27:16.733211 min lat: 0.0016877 max lat: 0.257525 avg lat: 0.034381
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   40      16     18330     18314   1831.16      1836    0.114651    0.034381
   41      15     18777     18762    1830.2      1792   0.0231119   0.0344147
   42      15     19256     19241   1832.24      1916   0.0281483   0.0343706
   43      16     19678     19662   1828.78      1684   0.0112887   0.0343865
   44      16     20116     20100   1827.03      1752   0.0388422   0.0344744
   45      16     20571     20555   1826.87      1820   0.0457656   0.0344798
   46      16     21039     21023   1827.85      1872   0.0351042   0.0344607
   47      15     21477     21462   1826.32      1756   0.0206584    0.034491
   48      15     21916     21901   1824.85      1756  0.00505084   0.0345191
   49      16     22378     22362   1825.24      1844   0.0492922   0.0345123
   50      16     22817     22801   1823.84      1756   0.0874689   0.0345343
   51      16     23266     23250   1823.29      1796   0.0554869   0.0345511
   52      16     23723     23707   1823.38      1828    0.046502   0.0345468
   53      16     24194     24178   1824.52      1884   0.0449133   0.0345267
   54      16     24673     24657   1826.21      1916   0.0242969   0.0344924
   55      16     25133     25117   1826.46      1840    0.117927   0.0344925
   56      16     25576     25560   1825.48      1772   0.0308638   0.0345085
   57      16     26033     26017   1825.52      1828   0.0229086   0.0345071
   58      15     26502     26487   1826.46      1880   0.0366591   0.0345002
   59      16     26952     26936   1825.94      1796   0.0328505   0.0345056
2019-02-26 21:27:36.735624 min lat: 0.0016877 max lat: 0.257525 avg lat: 0.0344872
  sec Cur ops   started  finished  avg MB/s  cur MB/s last lat(s)  avg lat(s)
   60      16     27414     27398    1826.3      1848   0.0153289   0.0344872
Total time run:       60.050631
Total reads made:     27414
Read size:            4194304
Object size:          4194304
Bandwidth (MB/sec):   1826.06
Average IOPS:         456
Stddev IOPS:          13
Max IOPS:             482
Min IOPS:             421
Average Latency(s):   0.0345121
Max latency(s):       0.257525
Min latency(s):       0.0016877
_______________________________________________
ceph-users mailing list
ceph-users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ceph.com/listinfo.cgi/ceph-users-ceph.com




[Index of Archives]     [Information on CEPH]     [Linux Filesystem Development]     [Ceph Development]     [Ceph Large]     [Ceph Dev]     [Linux USB Development]     [Video for Linux]     [Linux Audio Users]     [Yosemite News]     [Linux Kernel]     [Linux SCSI]     [xfs]


  Powered by Linux