On 07/10/2017 11:53 AM, Lennart Poettering wrote: > On Mon, 10.07.17 11:37, David Disseldorp (ddiss@xxxxxxx) wrote: > >> Thanks for the feedback, Lennart... >> >> On Mon, 10 Jul 2017 10:38:38 +0200, Lennart Poettering wrote: >> >>> On Wed, 05.07.17 13:01, David Disseldorp (ddiss@xxxxxxx) wrote: >>> >>>> Ceph relies on by-partuuid symlinks, in order to locate the journal >>>> partition from a given OSD partition. For details, see >>>> http://tracker.ceph.com/issues/19489. >>> >>> This appears way too broad, as it would apply to all LVM and all other >>> devices. >>> >>> It appears to me Ceph should do the same as LVM does for this, and >>> ship its own set of rules, and be careful to only match against the >>> actual devices it creates. >> >> We can certainly do this in a Ceph specific manner via the existing >> 95-ceph-osd.rules, but my impression was that the by-partuuid symlinks >> are "owned" by 60-persistent-storage.rules . >> >> If you don't think the existence of these symlinks for dm paths will be >> of use to others then I'll go ahead and propose it as a Ceph only >> change. > > Hmmm, so thinking about this again: "partuuid" is actually for GPT > partition UUIDs if I recall recorrectly, they wouldn't be generated > for DM devices anyway, since they are one layer removed from the GPT, > so are you even sure this will do what you are asking for? > > But even if this actually works: DM links so far are created by the > LVM/libdevicemapper/ packages, not by udev, and I don't think this > should change. Hence, please talk to the LVM/libdevicemapper folks > about this and ask them for including it. > Yes, please, any rules for symlinks which should be created under /dev/disk for DM devices (including all its subsystems like LVM, mpath...) should go into 13-dm-disk.rules that is part of LVM/DM source tree: https://sourceware.org/git/?p=lvm2.git;a=blob;f=udev/13-dm-disk.rules.in Now, when we create a partition over a DM device, there's a new mapping created on top for each partition (either by calling kpartx manually or by having it created by partitioning tool directly if it supports that). So in this case, it's not the kernel directly who creates the partitions, but they're simply another DM devices created on top of the underlying DM device to represent these partitions. But I think that doesn't matter - we should still create those symlinks for people to still have a possibility to reference the device by its part uuid - I'll fix 13-dm-disk.rules to include this. -- Peter -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe ceph-devel" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
