Hi Sage, I just tested v0.43. All pgs are shown active+degraded now. However, is it possible to show the number (or percentage) of degraded objects as in the earlier version? Henry 在 2012年3月2日上午12:14，Sage Weil <sage@xxxxxxxxxxxx> 寫道： > Hi Henry, Wido, > > On Thu, 1 Mar 2012, Henry C Chang wrote: >> With version 0.42, I found that the pg's state is not in "degrade" any >> more if the number of osds is smaller than that of the replication. >> For example, if I create a cluster of one osd with replication 2, all >> pgs are in active+clean state. (The pgs were in active+clean+degrade >> state in the earlier versions.) > > The PG states were tweaked a fair bit for v0.43: > > - new 'recovering' state means we are actively recovering the PG (no > longer implied by lack of 'clean') > - 'remapped' means we have temporarily remapped a pg to a specific set of > OSDs (other than what CRUSH gives us) > - 'clean' specifically means we have the right number of replicas and > aren't remapped. > > ...and the 'degraded' thing you are seeing is fixed. This is all in place > in the 'next' or 'master' branches. > >> I think it should be a bug in terms of cluster status although it does >> not cause any other problems to me so far. > > Yeah, it's simply a matter of how the internal state is displayed/reported > to the moitor. > > sage -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe ceph-devel" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
