At 09:14 -0400 26/9/07, Ross S. W. Walker wrote:
Could you try the benchmarks with the 'deadline' scheduler?
OK, these are all with RHEL5, driver 2.26.06.002-2.6.18, RAID 1:
elevator=deadline:
Sequential reads:
| 2007/09/26-16:19:30 | START | 3065 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p l -P T -T 30 -r (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-p u)
| 2007/09/26-16:20:00 | STAT | 3065 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total read
throughput: 45353642.7B/s (43.25MB/s), IOPS 11072.7/s.
Sequential writes:
| 2007/09/26-16:20:00 | START | 3082 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p l -P T -T 30 -w (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-p u)
| 2007/09/26-16:20:30 | STAT | 3082 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total
write throughput: 53781186.2B/s (51.29MB/s), IOPS 13130.2/s.
Random reads:
| 2007/09/26-16:20:30 | START | 3091 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p r -P T -T 30 -r (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-D 100:0)
| 2007/09/26-16:21:00 | STAT | 3091 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total read
throughput: 545587.2B/s (0.52MB/s), IOPS 133.2/s.
Random writes:
| 2007/09/26-16:21:00 | START | 3098 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p r -P T -T 30 -w (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-D 0:100)
| 2007/09/26-16:21:44 | STAT | 3098 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total
write throughput: 795852.8B/s (0.76MB/s), IOPS 194.3/s.
Here are the others for comparison.
elevator=noop:
Sequential reads:
| 2007/09/26-16:24:02 | START | 3167 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p l -P T -T 30 -r (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-p u)
| 2007/09/26-16:24:32 | STAT | 3167 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total read
throughput: 45467374.9B/s (43.36MB/s), IOPS 11100.4/s.
Sequential writes:
| 2007/09/26-16:24:32 | START | 3176 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p l -P T -T 30 -w (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-p u)
| 2007/09/26-16:25:02 | STAT | 3176 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total
write throughput: 53825672.5B/s (51.33MB/s), IOPS 13141.0/s.
Random reads:
| 2007/09/26-16:25:03 | START | 3193 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p r -P T -T 30 -r (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-D 100:0)
| 2007/09/26-16:25:32 | STAT | 3193 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total read
throughput: 540954.5B/s (0.52MB/s), IOPS 132.1/s.
Random writes:
| 2007/09/26-16:25:32 | START | 3202 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p r -P T -T 30 -w (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-D 0:100)
| 2007/09/26-16:26:16 | STAT | 3202 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total
write throughput: 795989.3B/s (0.76MB/s), IOPS 194.3/s.
elevator=anticipatory:
Sequential reads:
| 2007/09/26-16:37:04 | START | 3277 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p l -P T -T 30 -r (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-p u)
| 2007/09/26-16:37:34 | STAT | 3277 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total read
throughput: 45414126.9B/s (43.31MB/s), IOPS 11087.4/s.
Sequential writes:
| 2007/09/26-16:37:35 | START | 3284 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p l -P T -T 30 -w (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-p u)
| 2007/09/26-16:38:04 | STAT | 3284 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total
write throughput: 53895168.0B/s (51.40MB/s), IOPS 13158.0/s.
Random reads:
| 2007/09/26-16:38:04 | START | 3293 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p r -P T -T 30 -r (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-D 100:0)
| 2007/09/26-16:38:34 | STAT | 3293 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total read
throughput: 467080.5B/s (0.45MB/s), IOPS 114.0/s.
Random writes:
| 2007/09/26-16:38:34 | START | 3300 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p r -P T -T 30 -w (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-D 0:100)
| 2007/09/26-16:39:18 | STAT | 3300 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total
write throughput: 793122.1B/s (0.76MB/s), IOPS 193.6/s.
elevator=cfq (just to re-check):
Sequential reads:
| 2007/09/26-16:42:18 | START | 3353 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p l -P T -T 30 -r (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-p u)
| 2007/09/26-16:42:48 | STAT | 3353 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total read
throughput: 2463470.9B/s (2.35MB/s), IOPS 601.4/s.
Sequential writes:
| 2007/09/26-16:42:48 | START | 3360 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p l -P T -T 30 -w (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-p u)
| 2007/09/26-16:43:18 | STAT | 3360 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total
write throughput: 54572782.9B/s (52.04MB/s), IOPS 13323.4/s.
Random reads:
| 2007/09/26-16:43:19 | START | 3369 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p r -P T -T 30 -r (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-D 100:0)
| 2007/09/26-16:43:48 | STAT | 3369 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total read
throughput: 267652.4B/s (0.26MB/s), IOPS 65.3/s.
Random writes:
| 2007/09/26-16:43:48 | START | 3376 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Start
args: -B 4k -h 1 -I BD -K 4 -p r -P T -T 30 -w (-N 488259583) (-c)
(-D 0:100)
| 2007/09/26-16:44:31 | STAT | 3376 | v1.2.8 | /dev/sdb | Total
write throughput: 793122.1B/s (0.76MB/s), IOPS 193.6/s.
Certainly cfq is severely cramping the reads, it appears.
S.
_______________________________________________
CentOS mailing list
CentOS@xxxxxxxxxx
http://lists.centos.org/mailman/listinfo/centos
