Dear Joe,
Thank you for your response !
Regarding your questions，my answers are as follows:
SMM.7.1 - SMM.7.3:
Since we already have OpenIPMI and it is a commonly-supported utility, I only switched the disclosure as you suggested.
SFA.2.1: Live Kernel Remote Debugger
There is a ‘kgdb’ module in the version of kernel provided with our product, and I'm sure we can do live kernel debugging with this module.
SFA.2.2: Dynamic Probe Insertion
It is our mainline kernel that supports ‘Dynamic Probe Insertion’. And I'm sure the version of the kernel I'm shipping supports the features listed in this requirement.
AVL.13.1: Parallel User Initialization During Startup
We don't support this feature.
PRF.1.7: Handling Interrupts As Threads
This feature is supported by some customized products, but it is not convenient for us to disclose support for this feature.
SEC.9.2: Advanced Role-Based Access Control
We don't support this feature. So I left this claim as it is.
Accordingly, I amended the disclosure documents in response to the problem mentioned above. Please find attached our new version registration files for CGL 5.0. If you have any other questions, please feel free to contact me at any time.
Regards,
Celine
Software Engineer
Server R&D Department
KylinSoft Co., Ltd.
[ Enquiring the progress of KylinSoft CGL 5.0 Registration] On 21.02.21 (Sun 16:00) celine ksos wrote:
> Dear CGL workgroup,
>
> I sent our CGL 5.0 registration files to you on December 17，2020.
>
> I'd really appreciate it if you could tell me the registration progress.
>
> Please feel free to contact me at any time.
>
> Regards,
> Celine
> Software Engineer
> Server R&D Department
> KylinSoft Co., Ltd.
Hi Celine,
Please accept my sincere apologies for the delay in responding to yours
and the other CGL registrations.
With regard to your registration, there are a few minor questions:
* SMM.7.1 - SMM.7.3:
These are generally implemented via OpenIPMI. As you
already have OpenIPMI listed in your disclosure document
elsewhere, I recommend you simply switch the disclosure
here for the more commonly-supported utility. It
shouldn't require any work on your part other than
updating the document.
* SFA.2.1: Live Kernel Remote Debugger
Here you indicate you are implementing the feature with
'gdb'. Typically this has been implemented with either
'kgdb' or a proprietary solution in other registrations.
Are you confident you can do live kernel debugging with
the version of gdb provided with your product?
* SFA.2.2: Dynamic Probe Insertion
This is typically implemented with either kprobes and/or
LTTng. Your disclosure indicates it is a feature of your
mainline kernel. Are you confident the version of the
kernel you are shipping supports the features listed in
this requirement?
Other than that, everything appears fine as it is, though the review has
turned up a few minor things you may wish to amend in your disclosure
documents:
* AVL.13.1: Parallel User Initialization During Startup
This has been implemented by sysvinit and systemd both
from different approved registrations. Currently your
disclosures indicate you do not provide this feature. If
you would like to claim support for this requirement, you
certainly can.
* PRF.1.7: Handling Interrupts As Threads
This has been a feature in RT kernels for a very long
time, if you are supporting a RT Linux kernel, you can
claim support for this requirement.
* SEC.9.2: Advanced Role-Based Access Control
Since you already have a reference policy based SELinux
implementation in your product and that policy will be
able to support advanced RBAC features, you may claim
support for this requirement if you like. Of course if
this is a feature you do not actively support in your
product it is entirely reasonable to leave this claim as
it is.
--
-Joe MacDonald (on behalf of the CGL Workgroup).
:wq
Attachment:
Kylin Linux Advanced Server release V10(x86_64).xls
Description: MS-Excel spreadsheet
Attachment:
Kylin Linux Advanced Server release V10(ARM).xls
Description: MS-Excel spreadsheet
Attachment:
Kylin Linux Advanced Server release V10(MIPS).xls
Description: MS-Excel spreadsheet
_______________________________________________ Lf_carrier mailing list Lf_carrier@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/lf_carrier
