Solar Designer <solar@xxxxxxxxxxxx> writes: > However, in those (most common) cases when all you need is to concatenate > strings, relying on or providing an snprintf() implementation might be > an overkill. Gnulib's xvasprintf detects %s...%s format strings, which makes the code easy to analyse for that case. (Note that the x* memory allocation functions never returns NULL, it exits the program instead.) Unfortunately, it doesn't seem like this optimization has been ported to gnulib's non-x* printf replacement functions (snprintf, asprintf etc) yet. /Simon static inline char * xstrcat (size_t argcount, va_list args) { char *result; va_list ap; size_t totalsize; size_t i; char *p; /* Determine the total size. */ totalsize = 0; va_copy (ap, args); for (i = argcount; i > 0; i--) { const char *next = va_arg (ap, const char *); totalsize = xsum (totalsize, strlen (next)); } va_end (ap); /* Test for overflow in the summing pass above or in (totalsize + 1) below. Also, don't return a string longer than INT_MAX, for consistency with vasprintf(). */ if (totalsize == SIZE_MAX || totalsize > INT_MAX) { errno = EOVERFLOW; return NULL; } /* Allocate and fill the result string. */ result = XNMALLOC (totalsize + 1, char); p = result; for (i = argcount; i > 0; i--) { const char *next = va_arg (args, const char *); size_t len = strlen (next); memcpy (p, next, len); p += len; } *p = '\0'; return result; } char * xvasprintf (const char *format, va_list args) { char *result; /* Recognize the special case format = "%s...%s". It is a frequently used idiom for string concatenation and needs to be fast. We don't want to have a separate function xstrcat() for this purpose. */ { size_t argcount = 0; const char *f; for (f = format;;) { if (*f == '\0') /* Recognized the special case of string concatenation. */ return xstrcat (argcount, args); if (*f != '%') break; f++; if (*f != 's') break; f++; argcount++; } } if (vasprintf (&result, format, args) < 0) { if (errno == ENOMEM) xalloc_die (); return NULL; } return result; }