Well, after thinking about it (and talk with some friends, none lawyer), I just vote for "community cdrtools and dump cdrkit". I always think about supporting other operating systems, mainly FreeBSD and NetBSD, before taking place in disputes like this. "If the software can be ported to more platforms, then it is better mantained" was always a lemma from me (and many folks of NetBSD team :) ). So cdrtools is better quality software in my humble opinion. If the only reason to put it out of [community] repo is just a matter of FUD, then the only logical decision to take is to throw away the broken software. Arch shouldn't get carried by this type of rumours from no way.