Re: Apache Server status page shows uneven number of requests across load balanced web servers

[Arunkumar Janarthanan <arunkumar.webadmin@xxxxxxxxx>]

Gary,

Here is the netstat output attached from one of the webserver where the connections are on HIGH numbers. Regarding the load balancer I am trying to explore more setting options.

Thanks again for looking into this issue.

Best Regards,
Arun J

On Wed, Jan 27, 2010 at 2:49 PM, Gary Smith <gary.smith@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Arun,

 

This is just a WAG, but I think that the problem still lies in the client side and how the load balancer is handling the requests.  I would still be interested in seeing the netstat -atunep output  from one of he affected machines when there is a high level of connections in a closed state.  Even though the sessions aren’t sticky, is it possible that the load balancer is handling keep alive in such a way that it’s sending the back to the original server but on in a new state?  (that’s a little beyond my knowledge though). 

 

Gary Smith

 

From: Arunkumar Janarthanan [mailto:arunkumar.webadmin@xxxxxxxxx]
Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2010 11:37 AM

To: users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Subject: Re: Apache Server status page shows uneven number of requests across load balanced web servers

 

Thanks Gary,

The load balancing method we use is weight based, so apparently the load balancer suppose to send the traffic to the web server has least number of connections. However the Netscaler support confirmed they see eventual number of traffic routed to all 4 web servers.

Regarding the Apache restart time, I restarted all 4 servers same time and checked could still see the requests on 1 & 3 are being handled.  I dont think we have sticky session enabled at loadbalancer level.

For the same problem we have not before changed the load balancer settings from sourceIP persistence to Weight based to have the load distributed equal on all the servers.

                          IP     port         Type        State    Req/s

731-...30_80  x.x.x.x   80         HTTP           UP     16/s

731-...31_80  x.x.x.x   80         HTTP           UP     16/s

731-...31_80  x.x.x.x   80         HTTP           UP     14/s

731-...55_80  x.x.x.x   80         HTTP           UP     20/s

 

               Rsp/s   Reqb/s   Rspb/s ClntConn  SvrConn  MaxConn   SurgeQ

731-...30_80    16/s  12406/s 345117/s        7      285        0        0

731-...31_80    16/s  10956/s 365025/s        7      262        0        0

731-...31_80    14/s  11140/s 368655/s        6      268        0        0

731-...55_80    20/s  14322/s 420105/s        7      272        0        0

 

 

However the Apache server status still shows the number of requests being handled huge difference.

 

I have attached the balancer-manager page as well with this email.

 

Best Regards,

Arun J

Attachment: netstat-output.log
Description: Binary data

---------------------------------------------------------------------
The official User-To-User support forum of the Apache HTTP Server Project.
See <URL:http://httpd.apache.org/userslist.html> for more info.
To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
   "   from the digest: users-digest-unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
For additional commands, e-mail: users-help@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx