It was my understanding that in SLIMbus the Linux devices are created
at probe time, and when the device reports present this
'device_status' callback is used to notify the codec driver of a
change. The rationale for this was that the codec driver may control
power switches/gpios that are necessary for the device to appear on
the bus.
We use same rational here to power switch and flip reset pins in device
probe to power up the actual SLIMBus device in device probe.
Only difference here is that the actual SLIMBus device itself is
represented as many child devices based on there functionality.
SLIMBus parent device in this case is MFD device which is created at
probe time. However child devices for that device like gpio controller,
codec, clock controller and soundwire controller are created only after
the device is enumerated on the bus. Before that none of these devices
will be in a position to talk on the bus.
This argument was used to require an change in the SoundWire
implementation, so we followed this model of creating devices at probe
time based on information reported by ACPI/DT, and used the
'update_status' callback when the device is present on the bus (which
may happen after a delay or controlled by an external power switch).
This approach can lead to 'ghost devices' described in firmware but
not populated in hardware, and power management opens on how long a
bus needs to remain active if no devices report present.
What I understand from the code above is that the devices are actually
created when the SLIMbus device reports PRESENT, which seems a 180
degree change in directions?
Note these are the child devices of the MFD SLIMBus device.
Ah ok. I guess the creation of those child devices when the parent
SLIMbus device reports PRESENT initially if fine, it's the part where
you remove them if the device loses sync or gets powered off which is
odd. And I guess technically you could still have race conditions where
a child device starts a transaction just as the parent is no longer
attached to the bus.
I would however not remove the devices when the status is down but
only on an explicit .remove.
Am open for suggestions but I would not like the child devices to talk
on the bus once the SLIMbus device is down! Only way to ensure or make
it silent is to remove.
it's as if you are missing a mechanism to forward the parent status to
the children so use remove() for lack of a better solution?
_______________________________________________
Alsa-devel mailing list
Alsa-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://mailman.alsa-project.org/mailman/listinfo/alsa-devel
