WSJ: Airbus A380 Faces Operating Limits

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



This is from today's Wall Street Journal:

Airbus A380 Faces Operating Limit
Extra Restrictions on Big Jet Owing to Its Powerful Wake Are Likely  
to Remain Awhile

By ANDY PASZTOR and DANIEL MICHAELS
June 12, 2006

The Airbus A380 airliner, already buffeted by years of production and  
development headaches, is likely to face a daunting challenge once it  
enters service next year: unprecedented operating restrictions  
intended to protect nearby aircraft from flying into the air  
turbulence churned up by the superjumbo jet.

Rules that include special flight restrictions and extra spacing  
could pose an immediate marketing problem for Airbus because other  
planes in the A380's vicinity will likely have to either slow down or  
wait longer to take off to allow for the additional distance. Airbus  
designed and marketed the $300 million plane amid promises that it  
would fit seamlessly into existing global air-traffic patterns.

International aviation regulators and aerodynamic experts failed  
again last week to reach a consensus about the extent of the safety  
hazards created by the A380's unusually powerful wake, according to  
people involved in the deliberations. Meeting behind closed doors in  
Montreal, a study group including U.S. and European government  
officials continued to disagree about permanent safeguards to ensure  
that turbulence created by the A380 won't affect airplanes during  
takeoff, cruising and landing. In extreme cases, such turbulence is  
capable of wrenching even a large jetliner out of control.

Without a set of permanent standards, some version of the strict  
interim guidelines now in effect -- requiring at least twice the  
normal in-flight separation when trailing the twin-deck Airbus model  
-- likely will stay in place until well into 2007. Barring a last- 
minute breakthrough, these people said, this means that the world's  
largest passenger aircraft is poised to begin service with  
significantly more-stringent separation rules than any other jet.

Airbus has touted the 555-seat A380 as "the economical solution for  
heavily traveled routes." But the interim guidance from the  
International Civil Aviation Organization calls for minimum  
separations of 10 nautical miles for all aircraft following a landing  
A380, compared with the typical five miles required when following  
today's largest aircraft. For aircraft flying the same route directly  
behind an A380 at cruising altitude, the recommended minimum spacing  
is tripled to 15 nautical miles. A further complication is that  
controller organizations previously warned they may need as long as  
nine months preparation time to phase in new standards.

Airbus, which is 80%-owned by European Aeronautic Defence & Space Co.  
and 20%-owned by Britain's BAE Systems PLC, declined to comment on  
the turbulence issue. Some Airbus officials recently have expressed a  
willingness to accept a modified version of the present standards as  
a first step -- with the understanding that permanent rules would  
follow relatively quickly. The scientific work initially was supposed  
to be finished around the start of this year, but verifying certain  
computer-modeling techniques has been especially tough.

The strength of a wake depends partly on the weight of the aircraft  
that produced it. Wind and weather conditions can make turbulence  
hard to measure accurately around airports. Turbulence levels are  
also particularly tough to evaluate while a jet is climbing or  
cruising at high altitudes.

Since the controversy erupted last year, Airbus has invested millions  
of dollars and months of extensive flight tests to try to demonstrate  
that the wake of the 500-ton A380 poses no greater potential safety  
threat than turbulence generated by Boeing's largest model, the 747,  
which weighs about 100 tons less. There haven't been any recent  
crashes of jetliners attributed primarily to wake encounters, though  
over the years some business and private planes have experienced  
serious incidents and even crashed after following a larger aircraft  
too closely near an airport.

Industry and government officials on both sides of the Atlantic  
increasingly predict that Airbus will be forced to accept different  
rules than it anticipated. Andre Auer, head of the Joint Aviation  
Authorities, a European umbrella group with some regulatory  
responsibilities, said in an interview days before last week's  
Montreal sessions that the interim guidelines for the A380 "are  
likely to stay in place until commercial service starts."

The ICAO, which issued the preliminary safety standards in November,  
confirmed that no final agreement has been reached. The study group  
is interested in "harmonizing the new specifications, whatever they  
may be," so they apply equally all over the world, said spokesman  
Denis Chagnon. He added that the study group "is working well  
together" and hopes to issue a report in mid-November that ICAO  
officials could then review.

Privately, even some Airbus officials predict the A380 temporarily  
may have to be put into a new air-traffic-control category, until its  
safety is proved in actual conditions.
The A380 has faced other head winds, including a six-month production  
delay. Separately, engineers were recently forced to reinforce some  
structural elements inside the wings after they fell short on a  
stress test in February.

[Index of Archives]         [NTSB]     [NASA KSC]     [Yosemite]     [Steve's Art]     [Deep Creek Hot Springs]     [NTSB]     [STB]     [Share Photos]     [Yosemite Campsites]