Most Major Airlines Should Have Become Extinct

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



>From the Los Angeles Times

Last week's move by Delta Airlines to lower and simplify its fares might
trigger an overdue shakeout of the nation's airline industry, which last
year posted losses in excess of $5 billion and is more than $25 billion in
the hole for the decade. More of the nation's major airlines should have
become extinct by now - joining such hallowed names as Eastern and Pan Am in
the afterlife - but companies have been allowed to keep flying by overly
indulgent bankruptcy laws and clumsy government interference with the free
market.

No industry has done a better job of gaming the bankruptcy system. For
carriers like US Airways and United, bankruptcy seems less a safe harbor
from creditors in which to reorganize than an ongoing part of their business
plan. Flying under bankruptcy, as five airlines do, provides an unfair
advantage over competitors, a license to continue losing money without
facing the consequences. Worst of all, excessive reliance on this life
support has stymied overall development of the industry and slowed growth of
a new generation of healthy, low-cost airlines.

There is something about the airline business that turns members of Congress
from both parties into hopeless socialists, unwilling to allow the market to
allocate resources - in this case the skies, planes and those airport gates
- to their most efficient use. Members of Congress care deeply about
airlines, even beyond saving jobs in a given district, because they offer
the means of escape from Washington, not to mention sizable frequent-flier
awards.

The Bush administration deserves credit for resisting congressional
pressure, including from House Speaker J. Dennis Hastert (R-Ill.), to grant
airlines more aid on the bogus theory that their ongoing woes stem from the
Sept. 11 attacks. But there is still far too much interference with the free
market in the business, as exemplified by the government's refusal in 2001
to allow a distress merger between United and US Airways. Worse, Congress
has refused to lift antiquated limits on foreign ownership of U.S.-based
carriers, which has needlessly shut out investment capital and competition.

Without Washington's meddling, development of the multi-tiered industry that
has so benefited consumers would accelerate. By multiple tiers, we mean a
business in which not every airline strives to be all things to all people.

The older carriers' business model and labor costs were predicated on the
notion that you can be simultaneously Neiman Marcus and Wal-Mart. And they
would charge Neiman Marcus fares for Wal-Mart service if you deigned to fly
on short notice, or chose not to be stranded where you didn't want to be
over a Saturday night.

A multi-tiered industry would have fewer global and national carriers
engaged in more meaningful competition, and more regional, lower-cost niche
players. As the first of a new breed, Southwest Airlines - an enterprise
that has saved U.S. households untold billions - succeeded against the odds,
then beyond its expectations.

Southwest and newer successful low-cost carriers like JetBlue and AirTran
now carry nearly a third of domestic passengers. Their strength is
reinforced by the Internet, which robbed carriers of their pricing power and
shifted it to consumers.

Delta's move to cap last-minute fares and do away with Saturday-night-stay
requirements is a recognition that it's a new world out there for fliers,
one that no one in Washington should oppose.

[Index of Archives]         [NTSB]     [NASA KSC]     [Yosemite]     [Steve's Art]     [Deep Creek Hot Springs]     [NTSB]     [STB]     [Share Photos]     [Yosemite Campsites]