The article below from NYTimes.com has been sent to you by psa188@xxxxxxxxx /--------- E-mail Sponsored by Fox Searchlight ------------\ I HEART HUCKABEES - OPENING IN SELECT CITIES OCTOBER 1 From David O. Russell, writer and director of THREE KINGS and FLIRTING WITH DISASTER comes an existential comedy starring Dustin Hoffman, Isabelle Hupert, Jude Law, Jason Schwartzman, Lily Tomlin, Mark Wahlberg and Naomi Watts. Watch the trailer now at: http://www.foxsearchlight.com/huckabees/index_nyt.html \----------------------------------------------------------/ Some Light Shed on Panel Decision to Deny Aid to United August 25, 2004 By MICHELINE MAYNARD Members of a federal loan board said they felt that United Airlines' bid for $1.6 billion in assistance was based on a faulty business plan and they believed that helping the airline could hurt the rest of the industry, newly released minutes of the board's deliberations show. The minutes were posted yesterday on the Air Transportation Stabilization Board's Web site. They provide a view into two meetings in June, when United's second and third applications for federal assistance were turned down, forcing the airline to seek private financing. In turning down United's application, the board said that the company could find financing elsewhere and that it had not proved that the loan was needed to maintain a viable air transportation system. The minutes, however, show that members of the board also debated the financial underpinnings of United's case. A United spokeswoman, Jean Medina, said yesterday: "We disagree with the decision. Our business plan is built on very realistic assumptions. We know we have more work to do. We need to meet the challenges of the changing environment and extraordinarily high fuel costs." Last week, United, the operating unit of the UAL Corporation, said it was likely to terminate its four employee pension plans, and it has said it will not make required contributions while it is in bankruptcy. The threat has raised the ire of United's unions, and some of their leaders have blamed the loan board for United's decisions to stop the contributions. The three-member loan board was formed after the September 2001 terrorist attacks to administer $10 billion in loan guarantees made available by Congress to help the struggling airline industry. United's application would have been the biggest awarded by the board, which has provided assistance to US Airways, Frontier and America West, among others. United filed for bankruptcy in December 2002, after the loan board rejected its original application for $1.8 billion in guarantees. A year later, it applied for $1.6 billion, which it planned to supplement with $400 million in financing from J. P. Morgan and Citibank. But on June 17, Brian C. Roseboro, under secretary of the Treasury, joined Edward N. Gramlich, a Federal Reserve governor, in voting against United's application. The day before that decision, United's chief executive, Glenn F. Tilton, traveled to Washington to offer changes in United's business plan that the airline hoped would ease the package's approval. The appeal made no difference to Mr. Roseboro, according to the minutes. He said he did not think that a loan package for United was necessary to maintain the nation's commercial aviation system, and also said that outside financing was "reasonably available" to United. The minutes showed that Mr. Roseboro said he did not think United would face liquidation and that "providing a subsidy to a high-cost air carrier would likely have very negative long-term effects on the industry and competition," the minutes said. Mr. Roseboro also said that the Treasury Department "determined that the obligation would not be prudently incurred, specifically that the underlying business plan was built on unrealistic assumptions and the restructuring was insufficient." The minutes were not more specific. The board's executive director, Michael Kestenbaum, predicted that private investors "would likely require further changes to United's business plan," according to the minutes. Mr. Kestenbaum also said that asset sales could play a part in United's ability to raise capital for any restructuring. But United has said throughout its bankruptcy that it would not sell its assets. It told a United States Bankruptcy Court last week that its assets are pledged to secure its bankruptcy financing, which must be repaid when it emerges from bankruptcy. At the June 17 meeting, Mr. Gramlich, the board's chairman, praised the airline for progress it had made in bankruptcy, saying it was a "much improved airline" compared with the one that had applied for loan guarantees in December 2002. But Mr. Gramlich said airlines' access to capital markets was also much better than it had been immediately after the September 2001 attacks. According to the minutes, Mr. Gramlich said "there is a strong possibility that United would successfully emerge from bankruptcy without" a loan guarantee package, and thus he voted against the plan. The board's third member, Jeffrey N. Shane, an under secretary in the Transportation Department, abstained from voting, saying he wanted to defer a decision until the board could further examine Mr. Tilton's suggested changes. The rejection provoked a political storm that came to involve the White House, Congress and the Treasury Department. United ultimately cut its request to $1.1 billion, promising to find an additional $500 million in equity or equity-based financing on top of the $400 million already arranged. Treasury Secretary John W. Snow, who had received appeals on United's behalf from House Speaker J. Dennis Hastert and a senior Bush administration official, asked the board to consider a revised application from the airline. Mr. Hastert is a Republican from Illinois, which is United's home state. The action caused speculation that Mr. Roseboro might resign from the board in favor of someone who would back United's application, but he remained a board member. At another meeting on June 28, the board voted unanimously to reject United's third application. At that meeting, Mr. Kestenbaum said that United "did not address the statutory criteria under which its loan guarantee request had been denied," which was that a loan to United was not necessary to maintain the nation's commercial air system. http://www.nytimes.com/2004/08/25/business/25united.html?ex=1094452172&ei=1&en=8d9fa9f5cd9ce768 --------------------------------- Get Home Delivery of The New York Times Newspaper. Imagine reading The New York Times any time & anywhere you like! Leisurely catch up on events & expand your horizons. Enjoy now for 50% off Home Delivery! Click here: http://homedelivery.nytimes.com/HDS/SubscriptionT1.do?mode=SubscriptionT1&ExternalMediaCode=W24AF HOW TO ADVERTISE --------------------------------- For information on advertising in e-mail newsletters or other creative advertising opportunities with The New York Times on the Web, please contact onlinesales@xxxxxxxxxxx or visit our online media kit at http://www.nytimes.com/adinfo For general information about NYTimes.com, write to help@xxxxxxxxxxxx Copyright 2004 The New York Times Company