Re: Package Refinement

[Robert Denton <robert@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

I just did a test build with the sample I showed you before, and I  
included:

-@ dialup
-@ java

The install did not complain, but the files were still installed.  I  
am surprised that the install did not abort or ask for input. In the  
past when I have excluded packages from the packages list I had to  
add the arch (ex: -package_name.i386) or the install would die.

I am surprised you can have something in your packages list that  
means nothing does nothing and there is no complaint from anaconda at  
all.  The only packages where I include an entire group are for  
webserver and mailserver, and then I just remove the packages I do  
not need from them, like:

%packages --resolvedeps
@ web-server
-squid.i386
-webalizer.i386
-tux.i386
@ mail-server
-dovecot.i386
-spamassassin.i386
-@ dialup
-@ java

I also specify the following packages individually:

kernel
grub
expect
vim-enhanced
lvm2
perl
perl-libwww-perl
tcl
ntp
netconfig
wget

Oddly though there are a bunch of packages that do not seem to be  
related to the groups and are not in my list that get installed. Here  
are some examples of packages that I cannot explain how or why they  
were installed:

specspo (for internationalizing packages)
aspell
cracklib-dicts
xorg-x11-libs (I do not install a gui at all)


Robert Denton
Network Administrator
Headsprout
800.401.5062 x1305
www.headsprout.com

On Sep 26, 2006, at 3:53 PM, Shabazian, Chip wrote:

> I don't think you can remove a default package group this way:
> -@ dialup
>
> But, I've never tried it.....
>
> Other than that, yes your sample is fine, however I wouldn't add  
> entire
> package groups because you need a particular package.  Start with a  
> bare
> build.  In other words, have a %packages with nothing in it (unless  
> you
> want to try -@ dialup), then only add the packages you NEED to get the
> environment running:
>
> up2date httpd perl-libwww-perl
>
> This will resolve deps and give you a list of needed packages which  
> you
> can then add into your kickstart file if you wish.
>
> You can then figure out what you can REMOVE by removing packages.  rpm
> won't allow you to remove anything that's needed by another package
> unless you force it:
>
> rpm -e squid
>
> All of the packages you've removed go into your packages section  
> with a
> minus in front of them.
>
> Alternatively, you CAN go through the comps.xml and try to figure  
> it all
> out first, but I've found this way to be MUCH easier.
>
> This is a BARE MINIMUM I have come up with (RHEL3 I believe) that  
> still
> allows you to get into the server via ssh and load additional rpms
>
> %packages
> # you COULD delete the following, but I want them
> #-portmap
> #-openssh-clients
> #-openssh-server
> #-openssh
> #-openssl
> #-vim-minimal
> #-vim-common
> #-dhclient
> # To install a Minimum X environment, the following is all that is
> needed
> # XFree86-twm
> -cyrus-sasl
> -cyrus-sasl-md5
> -glib2
> -kbd
> -krb5-libs
> -libuser
> -openldap
> -tcp_wrappers
> -usermode
> -zip
> -xinetd
> -wget
> -vixie-cron
> -usbutils
> -up2date
> -unzip
> -unix2dos
> -traceroute
> -tmpwatch
> -time
> -telnet
> -tcsh
> -tcpdump
> -sysreport
> -symlinks
> -stunnel
> -specspo
> -slocate
> -sharutils
> -sendmail
> -rsync
> -rpm-python
> -rpmdb-redhat
> -rootfiles
> -rmt
> -rhpl
> -rhnlib
> -redhat-release
> -redhat-menus
> -redhat-logos
> -readline
> -raidtools
> -quota
> -pyxf86config
> -python-optik
> -python
> -pyOpenSSL
> -psacct
> -procmail
> -pinfo
> -pdksh
> -pciutils
> -patch
> -passwd
> -parted
> -nss_ldap
> -nscd
> -nfs-utils
> -netdump
> -netconfig
> -ncompress
> -mt-st
> -mtr
> -mtools
> -mgetty
> -mdadm
> -man-pages
> -man
> -MAKEDEV
> -make
> -mailx
> -mailcap
> -m4
> -lsof
> -lslk
> -logwatch
> -logrotate
> -lockdev
> -libtool-libs
> -libstdc++
> -libgcj
> -kernel-utils
> -kernel
> -htmlview
> -hotplug
> -hesiod
> -hdparm
> -groff
> -gnupg
> -gmp
> -ftp
> -file
> -elfutils
> -eject
> -ed
> -dump
> -dos2unix
> -diffutils
> -devlabel
> -cyrus-sasl-plain
> -crontabs
> -cpio
> -bzip2
> -binutils
> -bind-utils
> -bc
> -autofs
> -authconfig
> -attr
> -at
> -fbset
> -finger
> -iptables-ipv6
> -irda-utils
> -isdn4k-utils
> -jfsutils
> -jwhois
> -krb5-workstation
> -krbafs-utils
> -lftp
> -lha
> -libwvstreams
> -nano
> -ppp
> -prelink
> -rdate
> -redhat-config-mouse
> -redhat-config-soundcard
> -rp-pppoe
> -rsh
> -samba
> -samba-common
> -schedutils
> -setarch
> -star
> -sudo
> -talk
> -tftp
> -vconfig
> -wireless-tools
> -wvdial
> -cyrus-sasl-gssapi
> -ipsec-tools
> -libobjc
> -pam_smb
> -acl
> -apmd
> -aspell
> -cups
> -cups-libs
> -dosfstools
> -gettext
> -iptables
> -krbafs
> -libjpeg
> -libpng
> -libtiff
> -minicom
> -mkbootdisk
> -nc
> -ntsysv
> -pam_krb5
> -pax
> -pspell
> -rdist
> -redhat-config-network-tui
> -redhat-config-securitylevel-tui
> -redhat-lsb
> -setserial
> -setuptool
> -syslinux
> -utempter
> -ash
> -kernel-pcmcia-cs
> -yp-tools
> -ypbind
> -acpid
> -authd
> -diskdumputils
> -eal3-certification
> -eal3-certification-doc
> -iscsi-initiator-utils
> -jpackage-utils
> -laus
> -nss_db
> -pam_passwdqc
> -up2date-update
>
> Chip
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: kickstart-list-bounces@xxxxxxxxxx
> [mailto:kickstart-list-bounces@xxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Robert Denton
> Sent: Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:40 PM
> To: Discussion list about Kickstart
> Subject: Re: Package Refinement
>
> Thanks for the quick response.  So, if I do nnot use --nobase, but  
> want
> to exclude those default groups, can I do this:
>
> %packages --resolvedeps
> @ web-server
> -squid.i386
> -webalizer.i386
> -tux.i386
> @ mail-server
> -dovecot.i386
> -spamassassin.i386
> -@ dialup
> -@ java
>
> kernel
> grub
> e2fsprogs
> expect
> vim-enhanced
> lvm2
> perl
> tcl
> perl-libwww-perl
> ntp
> netconfig
> wget
>
>
>
> On Sep 26, 2006, at 3:32 PM, Shabazian, Chip wrote:
>
> > Sorry, in %packages, DON'T include version, and don't forget the s
> > like I did ;)
> >
> > %packages
> > -finger
> > -iptables-ipv6
> > httpd
> > perl-libwww-perl
> >
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: kickstart-list-bounces@xxxxxxxxxx
> > [mailto:kickstart-list-bounces@xxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Shabazian,
> > Chip
> > Sent: Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:28 PM
> > To: Discussion list about Kickstart
> > Subject: RE: Package Refinement
> >
> >
> > 1) You can figure out which rpm provides which file by using -qf:
> >
> > [root@someserver directory]# rpm -qf
> > /usr/lib/perl5/vendor_perl/5.8.0/LWP
> > perl-libwww-perl-5.65-6
> >
> > 2) If you want to exclude all those hidden packages, you can use
> > nobase:
> >
> > %packages --nobase
> >
> > However, doing this will require you to ADD a lot of packages back to
> > the build in order to get a bootable, useable system.  I find it
> > easier to remove unwanted packages and add the ones I want:
> >
> > %package
> > -finger
> > -iptables-ipv6
> > httpd
> > perl-libwww-perl-5.65-6
> > ... etc
> >
> > 3) You can use your standard redirects:
> >
> > rpm -q -a --qf '%10{SIZE}\t%{NAME}\n' | sort -k1,1n > /tmp/
> > rpms_by_size
> >
> >
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: kickstart-list-bounces@xxxxxxxxxx
> > [mailto:kickstart-list-bounces@xxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Robert Denton
> > Sent: Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:13 PM
> > To: Discussion list about Kickstart
> > Subject: Package Refinement
> >
> > Hello all,
> >
> > Now that I have the kickstart file mostly working how I would like  
> > it,
>
> > I would like some advice on how to reduce the packages installed to
> > the bare minimum for what I would like to do (simple webserver - not
> > exposed to internet). Here are some specific queries:
> >
> > 1. I have noticed that my perl scripts that use LWP will not work
> > unless I include @development-tools in the package list.  Since the
> > units I am building will not serve as workstations for development, I
> > would rather not install that group at all.  I am wondering
> > specifically what package in that group is providing the LWP support.
>
> > There are a lot of PERL related packages in @development- tools but
> > they all seem to relate to XML. The page I am relying on for info is
> > here:
> >
> > 	http://penguin.triumf.ca/comps/fc4/comps-v4-lang-en_US.html
> >
> > 2. "Default, Hidden"  There are two package groups that are listed as
> > Default, Hidden, which I am wondering if they are installed without
> > being listed in the packages group.  They are @dialup and @java.
> > Lets take dialup for example. @dialup includes the following
> > defaults:  ppp, isdn4k-utils, lrzsz, minicom, statserial, wvdial.
> > Oddly, everyone of these packages are installed although I did not
> > specify the group in the packages list.  Thus the 'Default. Hidden'
> > must indeed override the packeges list.  Is there some reason why my
> > system would need these files although there is NO modem?
> >
> > 3. I have found a way to list all packages installed, sorted by size
> > but I would love to redirect the output of the command to a file. My
> > usual bag of tricks is not working (cat, >, etc). Any suggestions?
> > Here is the command:
> >
> > rpm -q -a --qf '%10{SIZE}\t%{NAME}\n' | sort -k1,1n
> >
> > Thanks for any and all input!!
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > Kickstart-list mailing list
> > Kickstart-list@xxxxxxxxxx
> > https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/kickstart-list
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > Kickstart-list mailing list
> > Kickstart-list@xxxxxxxxxx
> > https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/kickstart-list
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > Kickstart-list mailing list
> > Kickstart-list@xxxxxxxxxx
> > https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/kickstart-list
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Kickstart-list mailing list
> Kickstart-list@xxxxxxxxxx
> https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/kickstart-list
>
> _______________________________________________
> Kickstart-list mailing list
> Kickstart-list@xxxxxxxxxx
> https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/kickstart-list