Re: that old GNU/Linux argument

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



Antonio Olivares wrote:
Why can't it be given as a gift, you are free to do whatever you want
with the cow. If you decide to let the cow eat hay and have calves, the
calves that you have can be shared with thy neighbor. This is what the
GPL enforces. The neighbor needs milk, he can milk your cow. Remember
the cow is licensed under the GPL.

It's a huge mistake to create analogies between information and property.

If the cow were software, you and I could both milk it. It would never run out. That's the way information works: you copy it and the original is left intact.

Property doesn't work like that. If you milk the cow, then the cow will need time to make more milk. I can't go and milk the cow immediately after you.

Analogies comparing property and information are misleading because of the fundamental difference between the two. Can we please not continue to compare software and property?

I would see real life examples like a teacher and a student. A teacher teaches a student many wonderful things say in mathematics.
That student learns and goes to higher and higher levels eventually
earning a Ph.D. The teacher is just a high school teacher, but was
the teacher of the student. The student comes up with a very famous
equation or proves a Theorem that has never been proven before. If
the student uses the GPL, he has to credit all of his teachers
including the one that taught him in high school. The student proved
the Theorem himself and he does acknowledge all of the teachers that
he had. All of the teachers can claim that they wrote the Theorem
also because they are protected under the GNU/GPL umbrella :) Is that
any justice to the student, who worked all the way up and did his/her
homework?

The GPL isn't about credit, it's about distribution and rights. Since you're talking about knowledge here, it's a somewhat better analogy than the cow. :)

If the teacher had given the student his knowledge under terms similar to the GPL, then that would not allow the teacher to claim that he wrote the student's theorem. It wouldn't even ensure that the teacher could later use the student's theorem to teach others (that'd be more like the AGPL). What it would ensure is that however the student applied the theorem, he would have to describe the theorem itself and all of the mathematical underpinnings that support it to the people to whom he distributes his work. He can charge money for his services if he chooses, but he can not hide the manner in which his work functions, and he can not forbid anyone from discussing his theorem once they've learned of it.

So, given that, do you think it's a good thing to forbid people from discussing the theorem that the student discovered? If so, why?

--
fedora-list mailing list
fedora-list@xxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe: https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-list
[Index of Archives]     [Older Fedora Users]     [Fedora Announce]     [Fedora Package Announce]     [EPEL Announce]     [Fedora Magazine]     [Fedora News]     [Fedora Summer Coding]     [Fedora Laptop]     [Fedora Cloud]     [Fedora Advisory Board]     [Fedora Education]     [Fedora Security]     [Fedora Scitech]     [Fedora Robotics]     [Fedora Maintainers]     [Fedora Infrastructure]     [Fedora Websites]     [Anaconda Devel]     [Fedora Devel Java]     [Fedora Legacy]     [Fedora Desktop]     [Fedora Fonts]     [ATA RAID]     [Fedora Marketing]     [Fedora Management Tools]     [Fedora Mentors]     [SSH]     [Fedora Package Review]     [Fedora R Devel]     [Fedora PHP Devel]     [Kickstart]     [Fedora Music]     [Fedora Packaging]     [Centos]     [Fedora SELinux]     [Fedora Legal]     [Fedora Kernel]     [Fedora OCaml]     [Coolkey]     [Virtualization Tools]     [ET Management Tools]     [Yum Users]     [Tux]     [Yosemite News]     [Gnome Users]     [KDE Users]     [Fedora Art]     [Fedora Docs]     [Asterisk PBX]     [Fedora Sparc]     [Fedora Universal Network Connector]     [Libvirt Users]     [Fedora ARM]

  Powered by Linux