On Mon, 2014-08-11 at 16:53 -0400, Jon Stanley wrote: > So I have to admit that I saw that Fedora badges were now being > awarded for kernel testing, so I went ahead and submitted my results. > In the process, I made a few observations (both on the process and on > the tests themselves): > > First from the process standpoint, has it been thought about to make > the process easier for testers than going to a webpage and uploading > results manually? Could we make it even easier by somehow asking for a > FAS identity and then uploading it? Yes, the code was just put into python-fedora last week to allow us to do CLI authentication, and now I am rewriting submit to make that work. It should be available at some point this week. > As for the test content itself, the test header has no information as > to what hardware it is running on, which for performance tests > matters, and possibly for some functionality tests as well (vendors > with buggy firmware, etc). I'm not sure what format patches are > preferred in, but there's a branch hw-info of > git://githuib.com/jds2001/kernel-tests that has this. A log header now > looks like: Thanks for the patch, I will take a look at it. To be honest when we first thought of it, we were worried about the balance of privacy. If we collect too much information, we might end up with fewer testers. I will mull it over a bit, but I don't think the information here would be too much. As for performance, user submitted performance data will be of less use anyway, as performance really has to be done in a controlled environment. Any time userspace changes, we have to rebaseline on a known kernel, etc. > Another test that would be worthwhile that I don't think I'm smart > enough to write on my own is whether AutoNUMA is working as intended. > This would of course require NUMA hardware (or booting a system with > fake NUMA). We can easily check for NUMA and simply skip if the test is run without it. I will add it to my list of tests to write. Thanks, Justin _______________________________________________ kernel mailing list kernel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/kernel
