Fedora's complete MirrorManager setup is still running on Python2. The code has been ported to Python3 probably over two years ago but we have not switched yet. One of the reasons is that the backend is running on RHEL7 which means we are not in a hurry to deploy the Python3 version. The mirrorlist server which is answering the actual dnf/yum queries for a mirrorlist/metalink is, however, running in a Fedora 29 container. This container also still uses Python2 and it actually cannot use the Python3 version. One of MirrorManager's design points is that the mirrorlist servers, which are answering around 27 000 000 requests per day, are not directly accessing the database. The backend creates a snapshot of the relevant data (113MB) and the mirrorlist servers are using this snapshot to answer client requests. This data exchange is based on Python's pickle format and that does not seem to work with Python3 if it is generated using Python2. Having used protobuf before, I added code to also export the data for the mirrorlist servers based on protobuf. The good news with protobuf is, that the resulting file is only 66MB instead of 113MB. The bad news is, that loading it from Python requires 3.5 times the amount of memory during runtime (3.5GB instead of 1GB). In addition to the data exchange problems between backend and mirrorlist servers the architecture of the mirrorlist server does not really make sense today. 12 years ago it made a lot of sense as it could be easily integrated into httpd and it could be easily reloaded without stopping the service. Today the mirrorlist server and httpd is all part of a container which is then behind haproxy. So there is a lot of infrastructure in the container which is not really useful. To get rid of the pickle format and to have a simpler architecture I reimplemented the mirrorlist-server in Rust. This was brought up some time ago on a ticket and with the protobuf problems I was seeing in Python it made sense to try it out. My code currently can be found at https://github.com/adrianreber/mirrorlist-server and so far the results from the new mirrorlist server are the same as from the Python based mirrorlist server. It requires less than 700MB instead of the 1GB in Python with production based data and seems really fast. I have set up a test instance with the mirror data from Sunday at: https://lisas.de/metalink?repo=updates-testing-f31&arch=x86_64 https://lisas.de/mirrorlist?repo=updates-testing-f31&arch=x86_64 The instance is based on the container I pushed to quay.io: $ podman run quay.io/adrianreber/mirrorlist-server:latest -h With this change the mirrorlist server would also finally switch to geoip2. The currently running mirrorlist server still uses the legacy geoip database. After the Fedora 31 freeze I would like to introduce this new mirrorlist server implementation on the proxies. I already verified that I can run this mirrorlist container rootless. This new container can be a drop-in replacement for the current container and no infrastructure around it needs to be changed. The main changes to get it into production is to change mirrorlist1.service and mirrorlist2.service to include a line "User=mirrormanager" and replace the current container name with new container. Adrian _______________________________________________ infrastructure mailing list -- infrastructure@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx To unsubscribe send an email to infrastructure-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Fedora Code of Conduct: https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/project/code-of-conduct/ List Guidelines: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines List Archives: https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/infrastructure@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
